How to create SUPERBABIES Professor Jonathan Anomaly https://desci.nyc/transcripts/how-to-create-superbabies Automatically generated transcript. May contain errors. [0:00] [Music] [Music] all right [Music] Final [Music] Countdown is it in frame is it in frame Nora Nora is it in frame careful careful is it in frame is it in frame like to many people [1:09] [Music] yeah hello hello hello hello hello hello hello hello hello hello hello hello hello hello okay everyone put that on um guys you guys two are thank you all for coming um if you can hear me top clap once okay wow that worked um we should have people come up in the front so we have a lot of space over here guys if you're in the back I'm [2:07] literally going to come by and like make everyone quiet if everyone in the back uh guys we're going to all have to be quiet or you guys if you guys want to chat you can uh leave um yeah sh yeah guys quiet and then yeah quiet and then turn around and tell the people behind you quiet and if you guys want to continue chatting you're more than welcome to go downstairs or out outside but um inside and can someone ask the bartender actually to turn the music off whoever's in the back here what guys if you're in the back can you be quiet and can someone ask the bartender to turn the music off [2:48] um bartender do you see me can you turn the music off this is yeah we're listening to Janet Jackson Jana Jana where's your where's Jana Jana can you go out oh can you can you ask to turn the music off okay and then everyone who's up front um swing around there's we're going to move people around so come up to the front yeah slowly everyone who's up here like move around up here uh do you guys want to come up uh then who you guys there's too many people you're not going to be able yeah come on yeah yeah come on and other [3:29] people come up come up come up like start leading the way cuz it's going to get noisy over there and you're not going to be able to hear I know it sucks but come on um come on yes come there's space over here and that'll allow people back there guys do you want to come up you guys yeah come on up people in the back come people in the back come up otherwise you're not going to hear her yay a few people more excellent really a few you will we'll [4:11] make it work there's a lot of space up here and then that'll allow people um in the back what I'll do it I'll do it oh yeah come come around the back um people people are on that side come around the back is okay thank you can you guys over there Tim Tim can you guys hear Tim sheet can you hear can you hear come up to the front come come up come up come up there's like space over here and then [4:54] it'll be it will make it short otherwise you're you're literally not going to be able to hear over there I promise okay I think this is the best we can do okay thank you all for coming um uh actually over here I didn't pay prices okay so um thank you guys all for coming I'll try and keep this short for the intro um first if you're enjoying the event we have our D NYC Twitter account we post funny things there and we have our Instagram account uh who uh raise your hand if you're helping run either the Twitter account or the Instagram account or you're taking pictures for it so give all these people a round of applause yeah raise your hand stand up stand up [5:35] de yeah Deja yeah Jana where's Jana thank you Jana thank you Jana thank you Victor anyone else anyone else who's helping to run it okay well thank you guys um it makes it much easier to do it together with them and um okay so this is wrong but oh well um uh if you want want to come to the next one the next one is on uh April 8th and it's the science of dongs so like internet of Internet Security for cyber connected sexual devices um we're having a guy who's from Germany he's very funny and he's very serious about this which [6:17] even adds to the humor um this was our last one I apologize uh I don't know why that's there okay um this we have these D meetups once a month this was the one with Brian Johnson honestly this is getting as crowded as that one was so that's cool and I hope everyone's like enjoying it and uh uh seeing things oh okay um so we're going to have a hackathon soon um so if people are interested like right now decentralized science is very much um like listening to a lecture and like meeting other people but I think it would be cool for those that are interested to like win win fabulous prizes and create science [6:58] knowledge so um we're going to have a hackathon centered around um like AI sleep and another topic clate climate yeah so that'll be really cool so if you're interested uh you can sign up here so I wanted to talk a little bit about um like what we what sort of sprung up D NYC um before doing this I was doing a PhD at Stanford and I was was curious about alternate ways to do science because I I was submitting papers and thinking like there must be a better way than like waiting 6 months to [7:38] hear back and paying like $5,000 and uh then getting these reviews back there must be a better way so I came up with this concept of like prediction markets for science so how many people were like during the election you know you weren't looking at CNN anymore to see who was going to win you were looking at like poly Market and saying like Okay poly Market is like the new thing that instead of quote unquote experts um experts running the show instead of like experts running the show it's going to be like citizens who are incentivized in the correct way so [8:19] similarly I like the previous way of doing it was like You' look at Fox News or CNN depending on which candidate you wanted and those would be the people that you'd sort of trust but the problem was those people who were running those things weren't incentivized to actually tell you the truth they were incentivized to tell you what you wanted to hear and that today is very similar to how science is done so science today is just the people who are 60 years old telling the other PE giving grant money to other 60-year-old people and accepting other 60-year-old people's papers into the journal that are run by this same cohort and it's just this sort of migration of people that all think [8:59] the same way and I'll want to do the same thing but this is just sort of an echo chamber and what you can do is you can break free of that by through the power of money and you can say like instead of just saying what hearing what you want to hear you can actually bet on which projects which science projects you think are going to work and which science projects are you're not going to work and if you're correct you earn money and if you're incorrect you lose money um unfortunately this is the old set of slides um so we're starting with um with uh doing this for Sleep which is really fun so we're conducting all these distributed sleep trials using an aing whoop or other type device and you can [9:40] participate in figuring out like you know sleep is very important in figuring out what is the future what how how how aware of the situations you are how smart you are how long you're going to live it's one of the most important predictors of that so we're trying to create a distributed clinical trial sort of situation where people are testing different drugs different peptides different interven and people are betting on which um which of these things are going to work or not and from this data set that we're collecting you can sort of sleep submit your data earn tokens and then use those tokens to bet on which interventions are actually going to be successful um in in helping people get better sleep and then once we have that uh expand from there so if you'd like to work with us um we're [10:21] hiring specifically we're really looking for um designers or game Engineers uh people who've developed like games um people who are good with social media we have all the different roles up there so if you're looking to um if you're looking for a job or uh you know someone that is looking for a job um I would encourage you to scan this and apply okay um okay so now without further Ado I'd like to introduce our does anyone have any questions three two okay everyone's shy okay so without further Ado I'd like to introduce our speaker Professor anomaly what a name that's I'm sure that's the first time [11:02] you've ever heard that joke and um he's doing some really interesting stuff around the future of having babies right so right now you rely so much on chance when you have a baby and in the future it's going to be very very different and I'll let him take it away with how that's going to happen [Applause] so does the M actually project out or is it just the microphone it's just for the recording do you want it should I use the hand I think you should I can actually no no no no you should use it [11:43] you should have to use this I will okay I used to do this for giant classro I'll move out of the way in a second let me just gete [11:59] oh let's do a picture okay um all right Smile everybody three two one and then we'll do one [Music] more it's okay okay we'll do one more all right oh my gosh you don't in say babies say babies super babies babies yay okay all right go ahead Dr anomaly and do you have a clicker um no it's just press it here okay that I 30 more seconds [12:56] promise can you guys hear that yeah all right good to go go ahead go ahead okay in that case set this up here and just be quiet dur the perfect all right well thanks for having me guys um everything here is decentralized even the production so science camera everything all right so yeah I'm just G to probably talk for about 30 minutes uh I I guess I should [13:43] say something about how I got interested in this some of my old students are here this is great we've got Duke UNC Penn and even Ecuador we've got University of the Americans louder okay yeah I'll keep this really close so um if you guys move up you're going to hear it better sorry no I'll just I'll keep it closer to my mouth I'm not used to the uh I usually use the lapel mic not this but anyway um yeah just briefly how I got interested in this topic maybe about 10 years ago I saw that well we'd all seen headlines about crisper not much about embryo selection which is what I'm going to focus on today but I thought of as just [14:25] sort of an interesting intellectual puzzle I was always interested in game Theory and ethics and modeling Collective action problems so what what happens when each of us chooses rationally but the aggregate result is either good or bad from a social standpoint you know we tend to think in economics when when there's some good aggregate result we want more of it we want to subsidize it or at least leave people free to create it in the decentralized spirit um and when something's bad what do we do we tax it we regulate it we ban it or we have social norms or moral emotions that are evolved to try to shame people for for doing actions that are maybe good for them but socially bad these are the [15:06] classes of problems I'm interested and I thought yeah what's going to happen when we all have the power to shape the genetic endowment of our kids is that going to be good or bad from a social standpoint across many people across many generations that's the origin story maybe it doesn't matter much um yeah I wrote up my uh my thoughts in a little book called creating future people the science and ethics of genetic enhancement and back in 2022 when I was living in Ecuador I was contacted by some people who were doing the thing that I wrote about and I joined the team we're a company we're in stealth mode for a bit longer but I'm going to combine some of what I was thinking about while writing [15:49] with what I know to be possible now um in specifically with embryo selection so that's just a brief uh preface and let's get started okay so the first question is what do we know about heritability um and it turns out we can know a lot about heritability without knowing almost anything about genetics how is that possible through twin studies or so-called behavioral genetics and the idea here is the the specific example that's usually used in the literature is twins that are raised apart but share either all of their genes or half their genes right so take monozygotic twins or triplets or [16:32] quadruplets and sometimes they're adopted out in very different environments and they're raised you know with the same genetic endowment as the other kids in different environments can we use that to tease out nature and nurture turns out we can actually we can do a pretty good job of that any measurable trait whether it be height that's easy personality medical history how much of that is influenced by just your genetic endowment versus versus uh social factors and I should say before I give some heritability scores that we know from twin studies what does heritability mean actually this is a trick question so let me ask you guys who's got a good definition of [17:12] heritability can someone tell me from the audience this is decentralized after all yeah the Vari good okay yeah the first half of that is sufficient and really nice and simple so heritability measures the variance within a population which is really important um that genetics is contributing to a particular phenotype or trait an outward manifestation of genotype could be height could be Health whatever we're talking about that's super important I wasn't going to spend any time on this but I will because it's frequently misunderstood if we say that height is [17:54] 90% heritable does that mean that it's true everywhere and for everyone and the the answer is no why would height be less heritable in some environments than others even if it's the same genes can anyone think of a good reason environmental yeah nutrition yeah that's the most obvious environment yeah that's one aspect of the environment so I mean you know nurture isn't going to do it it's not going to make you any taller but nutrition will um so you know interestingly enough take a country with big variation in wealth like India take a place like Bangalore that might be the most extreme you've got India's Silicon Valley so the richest people living in really clean conditions with you know [18:34] really good nutrition with some of the poorest people on Earth will heritability be the same there as it is in England and the answer is clearly no the genes are the same but the heritability score changes and I wanted to say that simply because just to get it out of the way when we use that phrase often we think of what's inherited genetically that's sort of true but it's only true in idealized environments okay so what do we we know about the heritability of certain traits I'm just going to go through a few um just cuz it's fun and these are yeah these are worth knowing about height no surprise highly heritable IQ that actually surprises a lot of people and again I will give the caveat that's going to change in different societies [19:14] so if you've got unequal access here's where education actually would matter at least a bit it's probably overvalued I mean probably people think education does more than it does but but it clearly does influence IQ there's no doubt about that so does nutrition genetics influence is a lot personality I don't know why people are surprised by that I mean just if you have a sibling like come on you guys are very different you grow up in the same household it's like your mom didn't do that well she did it but not in the way she thought she did political orientation and religiosity are two of my favorites so both are about 40% heritable um even if you live in a society that's all and only Muslim for example I lived in Saudi Arabia One [19:54] Summer you know who's going to be the most fervent Muslim in that Society probably the person who has like a higher heritability like a higher polygenic score for religiosity um even if it's impossible to be an atheist in a society people who tend to think in more liberal ways right it's probably tracking things like openness and other personality traits but as it turns out these things are heritable and probably not surprising what made us human is our brains and our ability to coordinate action what did that it's like a bunch of personality traits and intelligence and stuff like that right the ability to read cues from each other share information or manipulate people who are sharing information right melanism is also going [20:37] to be highly heritable no surprise there I guess really when you think about it um now I want to say just a bit about how we would understand the genetics of these so I mentioned that you could just do twin studies over and over again repeat them across different societies and you get a pretty good estimate of how heritable these traits are by just following people up through their lifetimes and very different environments and just measuring how different how similar are they okay but now let's get into the genetics of it and then I'll talk about how we can exploit the genetics or our knowledge of the genetics in order to um well I guess the title of the talk is something about super babies I don't know it's like a newspaper article like you have to have a sexy title um but [21:19] really it's more just in terms of yeah if we're doing embryo selection or eventually editing you know tinkering around the margins it's probably not going to be created anything from scratch anytime soon okay so how do we know something about you might say the genetic architecture the genetic foundations of these traits and one way to answer that is through genome white Association studies so these are only possible once sequencing gets gets cheap and accurate and the idea is if you sequence a large number of people and you either pull their medical records like you can do in in the UK because there's an NHS and there's a UK biobank and you could just match people up with their medical records or you get people [22:01] to in the spirit of decentralization again you could do a private biobank there are private biobanks where you sequence people you have to have a large number of people maybe sequence them for really interesting traits maybe you want to figure out something about violence and or or pass extreme passivity you know people you know they they may or may not be in a normal biobank you might want to go to the places where those people are in order to see sequence them in order to figure out like what makes them tick to some extent that might be different from Ordinary People mostly these things are going to be additive so it's going to be similar genes they just have more or or whatever of them but in some cases there might be some really unusual um genetics [22:44] for some of these people so what do we do well you gather all these these uh genotypes uh the you know the genetic sequence of all these people phenotype them measure how tall they are do they have breast cancer diabetes and with big enough samples you can create socalled polygenic rist sces and the idea here is that for most of these traits that are additive it's not one gene it's not 10 genes it's not 20 it's hundreds or thousands of small genetic variants that add up to an overall probability that either an adult has diabetes or will develop it or that an embryo would develop diabetes given the same kind of nutrition that it would [23:25] have for another embryo same thing goes for schizophrenia same thing goes for height for almost anything that you care about so polygenic RIS scores are really just scanning the entire genome more or less of millions of people hundreds of thousands of people figuring out which genes are correlated with which traits and then developing polygenic risk scores to be able to predict those traits particularly for embryos if you want to know ahead of time if I implant embryo a rather than embryo B you might want to know what's the relative chance that embryo a will develop schizophrenia or will be tall or short or whatever else actually let me ask you another question how would we know whether [24:06] polygenic risk scores work unless we wait for you know hundreds of thousands of people to be born and then measure them in the future I mean how could we possibly know if these things work you might know but um does anyone know how can we validate polyenic risk scores using existing people yeah you use an independent population to confirm or negate whatever the predicted risk score is so you have a discovery set and a validation set yeah exactly so that's that's one clear way of doing it so you've got a big biobank like the UK biobank or some other one you use one part of it to generate your risk scores and if you want to test how accurate are [24:46] these well you can just access let's just call it the the raw DNA from another part of the biobank or use another biobank alt together and just see you can see how accurate your risk scores are and some are going to be more accurate and others less but in other words you can validate that these things work before a single person was even born if you were using them to guide for example embryo selection similarly a more expensive but but even better way to do it is take existing brothers and sisters from large families so they have the same genetic relationship to each other as embryos do in a Petri dish right and that means if to take a simple trait like height you know you can just measure someone it's really easy to see [25:27] you have a poly I enic risk score for height you want to test it out find a really large religious family typically is religious and you know measure all the brothers and sisters after you've applied your polygenic risk score to their raw DNA and see how accurate it is um I think this is really important because in the future there are going to be a lot of companies offering polygenic risk scores there already are and some of them are going to be a lot better than others and you're always going to want to know like how did you validate these how do we know you're telling the truth you better publish some stuff here show us that they actually work um okay that's all a preface to the main to the main show here so how do we [26:08] influence children's traits then well the old-fashioned way is of course mate selection you know sexual selection is the thing that Charles Darwin focused on more than anything else after he invented his theory right he wrote a whole book about it um and you know essentially when we're selecting a mate it's often tracking genetic fit in the following sense you know people are attracted to some extent to to youthful looks right why would they care about youthful looks well young people are more fertile um so if you want a higher probability you're going to have a kid and the kid Will Survive into adulthood you know go other things equal with a young person or someone who's got a youngl looking face what else do we [26:49] find attractive a sense of humor why do women care so much about a sense of humor I think probably it has something to do with creative displays of intelligence I don't know know could be it's just guess but you know when you find these cross-cultural things like wherever you go you know there are things that people are attracted to and you think okay probably this is tracking something related to Fitness to differential Offspring survivability and so on so we already select mates on the basis of these things right we find sense of humor attractive we find facial symmetry attractive youth Etc smooth skin all right now to the fun stuff um Gene editing is a thing that I'm not [27:29] going to talk much about but of course this is going to be the main game in town I don't know in a generation or so I think it's going to take a little while what's the problem with Gene editing now I think like first of all we're we're not even sure that he jenu or you pronounced his name even did it if he did do it um he seemed pretty incompetent we have the emails from his correspondence with his Stanford mentors and yeah it was pretty experimental if he did it at all um there's no direct evidence that he that he edited the ccr5 gene let's say that he did it that's one gene but we've got billions of base pairs and I already mentioned that [28:10] almost everything you care about is highly polygenic it involves thousands and thousands of small genetic variants well one of the problems with using crisper right now is of Target mutations even the successors to crisper often produce these so you want to hit one Gene and you accidentally edit another Gene that could be really bad depending on what it does and the other thing is I've mentioned that you could know heritability scores without knowing any genetics that's sort of true and then I mentioned one way of figuring out what genes are associated with traits their gen and white Association studies but as we all know here like correlation and causation are different and we'd really want to know the full causal influential [28:52] architecture of the genetics of a trait before we go around editing it right so there's really two problems with editing right now and I'm sure they'll be solved but right now we don't really understand the genetic architecture of complex traits even if we know which of the genetic variants are correlated with those traits that's not a problem for embryo selection it's also not a problem for using polygenic scores yourself to figure out are you predisposed to heart disease with some probability you know polygenic RIS score is going to say yes and here's the probability and you can do that without knowing why and we don't know why and until we know why you're probably not going to want a Cris for your kids even if you could so now the boring but but true [29:37] part of this how you can actually influence your kids traits right now and there are a couple of companies that are out there in the open and there are a bunch more that that are in stealth that are coming very very soon um all of which already serve customers by the way and that is embryo selection using polyenic scores so IVF is of course inro fertilization PGT is just pre-implantation genetic testing so um one point to make about this is that the gains from embryo selection using polygenic risk scores depend on the number of embryos you have and young people in this audience you're probably familiar a lot of your professionals some work at places like Google or SpaceX or whatever and you [30:19] know they often offer egg freezing as a benefit now they're doing it selfishly they just want you to delay reproduction so you can be a slave to the man or whatever for a few more years years but actually it's probably good for you in the following sense if you don't yet have a partner even though it's a bit more efficacious to freeze embryos than eggs because you'll lose a few eggs when you freeze them and unfreeze them and so on when you're young you know you can get a lot more embryos and at much higher quality it's shocking how quickly that declines with age and with age I mean like after 20 not like after 38 or whatever like it's just a continual decline for men too you know some men I go around telling men to freeze their sperm now because you know uh sperm [31:01] mutate or at least the the organs that produce sperm mutate and pass along mutations and so you know older men have higher risks of things like low functioning autism and even to some extent schizophrenia and so yeah um it can be a good idea to do that for for that reason but also for this reason just think about the number of embryos that you have as being a proxy for genetic diversity the more you have if if you're interested in some trait like schizophrenia runs in your family or extremely short stature something like that well if you have 10 embryos probably one of them is like average height or pretty low risk of schizophrenia and probably two or three are it's going to be in many cases [31:43] continuous and the same thing goes well I've got IQ here because that's a sexy one the best predictors right now they're still private the the validation studies will be published very soon publicly but the best predictors say that we can get you know about a dozen to 15 IQ points in terms of the spread between the lowest and the highest scoring embryo that's getting pretty close to half of the actual variation so the actual variation in IQ between 10 embryos is going to be about double that about 30 points that's a lot when you think about it two standard deviations so if you have a large family what you'll see in front of your eyes is Big variant right you can have the same you [32:23] know the same parents but you see really really big variant in personality and intelligence and height and all kinds of stuff so yeah the gains from emry of selection depend on the number of embryos you have and one way in which this is going to be supercharged we think I think it's coming soon everyone always says five years though it's one of those things in five years it'll all be there I think probably let's call it eight years I'll just be a little bit more conservative in vitro gam Genesis what is this someone can someone explain it in like one sentence what's the quick version of this may have a little diagram here but yeah why not creating cells yeah that's a quick way to do it [33:04] creating EG cells in love so taking adult cells yeah everyone knows these is skin Could Be Blood whatever uh taking them turning them into induced plur potent stem cells right and then from that you can get any kind of cell but if you can do that then you can get an egg so you could imagine a Vio blood giving you a th000 a th000 uh egg cells or something right it's probably more than that I'm just making that number up but imagine going from three or five embryos to 3 or 5,000 embryos and now suddenly you're talking about enormous variation um there are diminishing returns I should say that after after certain numbers nevertheless you could like dramatically transform your children [33:44] just with that alone even if you never edited a single a single Gene so that is on the horizon it's been done in other animals I assume it will be done on people unlike embryo select I think it's going to be um highly regulated at first I doubt that the FDA will like allow it immediately but that's what places like prospera are for um there are startup cities around the world where of course people are essentially going to allow and even encourage labs to open up there to basically you know operate as an Arbitrage um for people who want to do this okay so I just thought I'd go through a couple more set pieces and [34:25] then open it up to Q&A because why not um although I have a couple a couple of I don't know surprising points to make so what are the benefits of minimizing genetic disease this is Almost Boring right so obviously right longer better life healthier life Etc um you know social productivity blah blah blah that's not that interesting um now what about IQ I find this interesting not because I'm an IQ maxer but because I think a lot of people misunderstand the benefits of IQ it's obvious that intelligence has something to do with computational power we all know what like one of your dogs is smarter than another we know what that looks like everyone always like I don't even know what intelligence is or what is an IQ test we know what it is [35:07] everyone knows when they see it right do IQ tests perfectly capture it no but you know the ability to solve complex puzzles is something that obviously is a benefit in many ways but there's something much much more interesting that economists and game theorists have discovered in the experimental Arena that I thought i' that I thought I'd mention so let's see here yeah why would smarter people live longer or have better do better on health metrics there's actually a few possible explanations anyone have any ideas here better choices better decisions yeah that's exactly yeah filtering through you know bad information from good you know keeping [35:47] your appointments going to the doctor finding the better doctor not the witch doctor whatever right I mean that's kind of obvious but you know we underrate it I mean you know everyone in this room whatever is has passed some basic test and as Linda gotfredson like says you know life is an IQ test in a way right you're navigating complexity everywhere and if you're in this room you probably have made decent decisions about doctors but that's not true for everyone right they listen to gurus and they just kind of yeah they end up succumbing to their cancer more interestingly I think Steve Jobs yeah I didn't actually mean him but yeah and he is highq but um I think much [36:27] more interesting is this lower stuff and I actually don't think it has anything to do with computational power well obviously scientific innovation does but cooperation so groups of high IQ people are more Cooperative than groups of lower IQ people individuals don't matter that much but groups do anyone have any idea why this would be the case this is really an odd finding but yeah the the overall group um goal is more important than IND idual interests or desires yeah I mean I would say that but I don't think it has anything to do with IQ so the answer was like maybe the overall group goal you know people are [37:08] thinking about this and sticking to it and you know thinking less about themselves but I don't think smarter people are any less selfish than Dumber people there you go okay Ben Ben my star student from UNCC um so yeah um as usual Ben drives and gets the answer right you know nothing has changed in the last 10 years um yeah in repeated prisoners dilemas or public goods games and economics these are games I won't bore you with the details but where there's some you know what's individually rational is not necessarily collectively optimal so if you invest [37:50] some now for the sake of the group you know you're going to lose it now but the group will benefit if everyone does it and again smarter people aren't I think any nicer than less smart people but what they will do is they'll find the other smart people who make credible pledges and they'll surround themselves with them and they'll find strategies together to delay gratification now for bigger rewards later and so what you get is more cooperation in prisoners dilemas and public goods games and more use of altruistic punishment where you know that by pishing free riters now you can get more cooperation in future rounds like the worst thing you want to do is incentivize free riters right in a game [38:30] where there's a conflict between individual and Collective interest so that's kind of interesting and it's like a metaphor for bigger games that we play every day whether it's at work or in politics or whatever else and here I'm drawing on Garrett Jones he and I wrote a paper a while ago called um let's see here cognitive enhancement and network effects where we actually argue that despite the inequalities that might arise when already smart people are selecting for intelligence they're actually going to be positive not negative externalities for other people why because again even when they're mean smarter people tend to be more cooperative and therefore more productive which has positive externalities in other people there are negative externalities too right I mean [39:11] if genetic differences become so big that you can't relate to each other anymore on terms of equality I mean imagine like our relationship to chimpanzees they're lucky that we're nice to them they're they're kind of cute and interesting and so we preserve them but we use them they're almost like tools I mean we don't give them the right to vote like that's not going to be very interesting right and imagine you know inequality is that big you know that that would be actually concerning and interesting we could talk about that but in the absence of truly giant inequalities if you're just talking about you know some people boosting IQ by five or eight points or something in a generation I actually think that's going to be good for everyone not just for the people who who do it all right so what traes can we influence now this [39:53] is just a random list of some things yeah IQ schizophrenia bipolar disorder um some of these autoimmune diseases are important my grandmother had like seven of those um so you know she was the smartest person in our family and couldn't do anything you know grew up in New York and was a slave to the house because she couldn't leave the house because she had so many autoimmune disorders what if we could select for her brains and her beauty without the autoimmune disorders right I mean whatever you guys say I have no I have no hesitation to say what she would say she would love to not have those disorders why should we support genetic selection so this is more of a stock pitch um you [40:34] know why because I think we should be able to argue in favor of these things some people are creeped out by it or they just think it's you know against God's will or nature or whatever else I think you should have reasons for for for selecting in favor of or at least allowing genetic selection in favor of these traits the first is just a darwinian point and that is that nature natural selection sexual selection they don't necessarily select for human happiness or for human welfare they select they create creatures that are good at finding other creatures that are good at maximizing the numbers of copies of their genes uh viruses are really good at that some of us have them right now you know the ultimate winners in the evolution evolutionary Game of Life are [41:15] not you know smart gentle kind people we hope they are we and we we might be able to make it that way but the real winners are like viruses right they're the things that can like exploit and parasitize and that sort of thing but for the first time in history we're in a situation where we go look we're the product of evolution we're this mixture of imperfect you know emotions we're jealous we're mean we lie to people but we're also altruistic and we have ideals like Beauty and wisdom and truth and and and we can reflect on what things do make life go well and we can to some extent select for those things right what actually makes a life you know happy flourishing in the Aristotelian [41:55] sense so nature doesn't necessarily select for that and in fact in some cases the opposite as soon as you get a lot of really nice high trust people what does Nature Select for psychopathy according to Steven Pinker they're about 1 to 2% of the human population and you know it's clear it's an evolutionary strategy precisely to exploit nice people right if you can go undetected and you know essentially disguise yourself as a contributor to some collective Endeavor but meanwhile you're just exploiting all those people contribut actually you can probably have a lot of kids before you're found out and that's why it persists in the population maybe it won't persist that much longer though [42:36] maybe like taxs once we understand the genetics of it maybe people will select against it um and so maybe we won't be seeing much more of it so the first point is nature doesn't select for human happiness it selects for you know whatever produces copies of genes the second point and this is a big one and forgive me for quoting a couple people here but I think you'll find this interesting I hope so civilization preserves harmful genetic variants harmful recent mutations um Charles Darwin understood this before the concept of a gene was understood Gene was coined I think in 1907 the term everyone knew there must be some unit of heredity that natural [43:17] selection is acting on and Charles Darwin understood that whatever this unit is um in a modern civilized society where we have really good medicine really good nutrition he's thinking of England at the time what it's going to be good at is preserving people who would have died in ancestral conditions because they had poor eyesight now we could say Childhood Cancer you know what you're not going to do is say well my kid has cancer like throw them to the Wolves right you're going to try to treat it with with chemotherapy and surgery and radiation and and you should and and Darin thought so too of course you should do that this is the benefit of civilization but a side effect of that is [43:57] that the genes that produce those predispositions will almost certainly proliferate in modern populations that's not a problem in one generation or even two but across 5 10 20 Generations it could actually be a problem so Darwin says this is you know very colorful language so forgive me for repeating Darwin but with savages the weaken body or mind are soon eliminated and he's actually recognizing the benefits of this and those that survive commonly exhibit a vigorous state of health we civilize on the other hand you know we British with the crooked teeth and so on you know we do our utmost to check the process of elimination we build asylums for the imbecile the maimed and the sick we Institute poor laws which he [44:37] supported our medical men exert their utmost skill to save every life to the last moment no one however who has attended to the breeding of domestic animals will doubt that this must be highly injurious to the race of man um this is when people wrote with a seriousness they weren't worried about getting cancelled you can tell he actually cares about people which is why he's raising this point he's not signaling his care this is like a genuine care where you're like damn there are real trade-offs between civilization and genetic Health at least over long tracks of time yeah um there's a good article that I always mention on this because it's so so quick and you can find it by John Tubi just before he died called the race between germ L Gene [45:19] editing and genetic meltdown and that's a modern version of this talking about the proliferation of denovo mutations that are that are delarius so one way we could deal with this of course is return to the harsh conditions of you know natural selection throw the kids into the Wolves so to speak um or we can just let it keep happening right and just let people slowly melt down so to speak or you know we can steer things in our own direction we can select for traits that we think are valuable and we can select against genetic variants that are producing disease or Childhood cancer or whatever else it's pretty clear where I stand on this probably but I actually think as a talking point this gives us a [46:01] really good case conservative case you know you can think of why a liberal in the broad sense of that term would support this right it's individual Choice people have their own conceptions of the good you should allow them to have their own genetic information and choose accordingly and I agree with that but conservatives at least again in the broad sense of the term I hate talking about political parties because they're all but when you just talk about you know what are what is a conserv a in the real sense it's someone who like hang on you know rapid social change actually can be harmful and we can think of people like GK Chesterton who came up with the metaphor famously of chesterton's fence another quiz quiz time again guys just to make sure you're still awake um what is chesterton's [46:44] fence hey another former student that's cool um what is chesterton's fence can anyone uh explain that what's the yeah oh we've got to go ahead yeah speaking if you have a find out why cropped up andic there you go ahead and good yeah and in fact he says this in the context of social reformers and he means kind of radicals you know Marxist or radical progressives at the time you know he's a conservative and Christian and he's saying look if you're going to tear a fence down metaphorically you should probably know who put it there first and why it was built there may be very good reasons and what comes after the fence may be [47:25] actually quite dangerous um and many conservatives I think greatly employed this metaphor I think it's a very useful metaphor for you know really radical social change because often what comes next is worse than the thing you're trying to fix nevertheless I don't think that Chesterton can be unequivocally used to to to oppose for for example genetic enhancement or genetic selection here's another metaphor I call it chesterton's post it's from a book he wrote called Orthodoxy the other book is why I'm a Cath and here's what he says and I think you'll like the metaphor conservatism and this is a criticism of conservatism is based on the idea that if you leave [48:06] things alone you leave them as they are but you do not you leave a thing alone or when you leave it alone you leave it to a torrent of change if you leave a white post alone it will soon be a black post if you particularly want it to be white any other color you must always be painting it again briefly if you want the old white post you must have a new white post and I think this is a metaphor for it can be in this realm for look we're subject to a torrent of genetic mutations genetic degreg um there's nothing magical about where we are now natural and sexual selection incentivize all kinds of horrible Behavior as well as good [48:46] behavior rape is almost certainly natural in the sense of rapists are in many cases rewarded with more copies of their genes in future Generations otherwise it probably wouldn't be such a universal behavior when one military conquers another military what do you do you kill the men you rape the women it's right there in the Bible right kill the men and keep the woman for for yourself right this is as old and as normal as can be and yet it's completely evil right so we can agree that rape is both bad and potentially natural inclinations to do this could be natural is that something that we think is good or well [49:26] this is a kind of you know byproduct of an amoral set of forces but again we can kind of figure out what's good about human nature let's have more of it what's bad about human nature and what might be degrading in our genome let's have less of that okay a couple quick more points to support genetic selection and I promise these will be much faster one is the idea of evolutionary mismatch everyone's heard this phrase by now the idea that we've evolved in very different environments than we now live in you know here we are in New York City this is the perfect example of it you know the skyscraper is you know 100 years old um you know we haven't adapted to to life in tiny Apartments using you know [50:07] dating apps and things like this so we've recreated our environments in ways that actually make people more miserable sometimes that doesn't mean you shouldn't do it because if you're the only deviant from a new Norm then you're going to be the weirdo if you're not on the dating app even if dating apps make everyone worse off or if you have some other lifestyle that actually is probably more healthy like I'm going to go to bed early and not drink any alcohol like good luck going to the cool kids party and like finding someone to to hang out with right so you know you go to the old folks home instead so there are all kinds of conditions where our environment is very different than what we're psychologically sort of adapted to or physically adapted to everyone uses the example of cheap sugar [50:48] refined sugar obviously you know we have a taste for this but it's not good for us I want to use the example of you know thinking about how we've recreated environments in ways that are really beneficial to us when used well obviously the Internet it's kind of boring but true we can get all the information we want which can make us you know addicts which can make us worse off with the dating app example Etc but if used well it can make us better off so what do we do we enjoy we employ strategies psychological strategies to use these things well maybe you have more or less impulse control but you could also adapt people to the environment as well as you know adapting [51:29] the environment to people and to the extent that the new environments we've created free of germs for example relatively free we have higher rates of autoimmune diseases partly as a byproduct of that higher rates of asthma partly as a byproduct of that because we have fewer microbes and we were adapted to encounter microbes what do we do well probably you don't want to go back to a situation where you're just randomly having you know 40% of your Offspring dying in childbirth but you know you might actually reintroduce microbes in the hospital or something like the ancestral microbes or if you're George Church I'm not but you know he has a radical solution which is a lot of the viruses that assail us that kill us like [52:10] influenza or seriously imparis I just coughed because I had a virus those are relatively recent it's because of our our our encounter with animals during the Agricultural Revolution we get all of our influenza from other animals it's very recent well what if we either you know have artificial meat rather than animals so we grow them in a lab instead of animals I'm for that for a lot of reasons or you know we adapt ourselves so that we have an immune system that's essentially not capable of being penetrated by viruses um you know both Solutions are possibilities but I just want to mention this because I think this is an argument not to go back to where we might have been but forward to where we might be [52:51] finally I want to mention one more thing on this slide I'll just do a couple more and open it up um and this is a sometimes I call these Red Queen effects or arms races from Alison Wonderland um the point with number four here reason to Port direct next election it's really not to you guys you're all in this room it's to conservatives who are opposed to this or policymakers who think that by making it illegal or difficult that they're going to help their own population what's going to happen actually let me ask this does anyone know who most supports Gene editing embryo selection for you know cognitive ability for oh well sure sure yeah I mean [53:33] countries that's actually completely wrong everyone thinks that but we have evidence on it China is both behind in this and weirdly backward in their attitudes toward heritability it's India India is extremely supportive of this at least on surveys and Israel um there there are a bunch of other countries we just don't have good data for but but we have really good data for India for Israel for Singapore Singapore is very much in favorite I'll show you a slide later but for whatever reason I don't know why but India is much more supportive actually than China is maybe that'll all change I think preference Cascades happen once more companies come onto the scene offering this anyway the [54:15] point is once some countries or some people are doing this it's going to create an arms race which I actually think is socially beneficial others are going to be terrified by and that's because it's going to change incentives if I know other people are predictably selecting for certain traits it's going to incentivize me to either select for similar or complimentary traits if most people are selecting girls then it gives me a stronger incentive to select for a boy this prospects in the mating Market will be a bit better um other traits will be a little different and I'll get into how that might work but arms races are interesting because they can be a positive and negative or negative and B they change the moral landscape you [54:56] might have a moral intuition like this is wrong or this is cool or whatever you think but actually your intuitions are going to change dramatically when most other people are doing this right and suddenly it's going to reframe things for policy makers and individuals and I think it's an important point to make when you're thinking about reasons for selection okay I'll just end on this this is the topic of my little book um I'm not advertising this my company paid to make it open access anyway so I don't make any money off of it but um yeah you can access a PDF or there's this little version of it but like I said what motivated me to write it is just intellectual interest I was really interested in arms races like um [55:37] evolutionary arms races like antibiotic resistance and that sort of thing you know we take antibiotics and they cure the individual but a side effect is resistance and like how do we solve that problem you know perfect econ problem right Global intergenerational Collective action problem but this this is what I worried about for the book I think you know mostly selections would be good but what about you know imbalanced sex races sorry sex ratios really really tall boys where everyone selects for height so there's no relative Advantage anymore to being taller because everyone's taller but we have more you know joint problems or cardiac problems as a as a side effect you know these are positional Goods arms [56:18] races where you only want more relative to somebody else right it's not like just having it is better there's nothing good about being tall there's really only bad things except given female preferences and given our current environment it's actually much healthier to have like a gymnast body right like what's your average male gymnast like 5' seven really healthy really stocky you know like that's probably the ideal male body but does anyone think that's the it's like you pull the ladies in here and pull the employers and who they're going to hire or vote for for president cuz that's how ridiculous we are right the taller guys like more authoritative and smarter like that's how we think that's absurd and obviously false but if [56:59] everyone chooses that way you know you get these kinds of problems and then immunity monocultures my solution pretty simple this is the boring part you know I still think that generally speaking we should leave people free to to choose what they will for their kids they have the better incentive to figure out what what their kids would benefit from and act on it than government agents ever would so this would be an argument for individual selection rather than you course of eugenics from a government or something like that but when we do need a rule to solve a serious Collective action problem this is going back to something The Economist side me would Advocate and that is something like regulatory parsimony we should have simple laws that apply to all rather [57:40] than a complex network of rules and laws and here's why um first of all if we have really complex laws or restrictive laws who can get around them people who can afford to travel you know India is a big place for organ markets um people travel there to get a new organ but because you know India India has made it illegal that actually raises the price even higher and so now instead of people selling their organ voluntarily people are kidnapped and murdered for their organs and then their body is just thrown to the side Colombia also has a pretty thriving black market and organs as well so a lot of times when you regulate things like this you get these [58:22] unexpected costs as well as benefits and I'm not sort of preaching about politics here I'm just sort of saying you got to pay attention to those who can afford to get around those laws it's always the rich and well-connected and who are the victims of those laws it's always the poor and poorly connected um similarly too many laws can crowd out social norms that can effectively equilibrate arms races so for example um if we take a a situation like sex selection or height selection first of all there is a kind of natural limit to how tall you would want your kids to be everyone will quickly learn like if you go above say 63 for men you do start having these these problems and [59:02] most people even if women are attracted to tall men which they are in general when they're deliberately choosing the traits of their offspring they care a lot less about that superficial stuff and more about like Health mental health well-being achievement productivity will they have good friends good relationships and just like maxing out on like height is not really something that they'll do probably better not to ban it but to just allow that self-equilibration to happen through social norms restrictive laws I already mentioned yeah black markets and learned helplessness the more complex something is the more restrictive it is the more people tend to just abdicate reason and [59:42] just follow the rulle slavishly but strangely enough the more Liberty they have the more incentive they have to figure out like okay what's real here what is this company promising me is it is it snake oil or is it real um and like how would I really think about the the traits I want my kids to have so I'm going to end on this slide and that is two recent surveys one from 2023 in the US and one from Singapore last year and what this did just to give you a sense of how many people already support even the more kind of controversial trait which is intelligence selection already people of reproductive age in the US um admit you know nearly half would would [1:00:22] select for a cognitive ability would they edit the genes it's a little less than that but a lot of this is just because we can't do that so it's kind of a weird question to ask um as it's more feasible maybe they will but when you look at a place like Singapore turns out like 60 to 70% would select for cognitive ability the true answer might be even higher than that but that's the best survey evidence we have right now the other questions are about Gene editing and SAT prep weirdly like only 80% would do SAT prep and when you ask them is it moral like 20% say it's immoral I don't know maybe it's because they think it's a collective action problem and so a solution to it is to just say no one should take SAT prep maybe it's [1:01:02] actually wise anyway my view of this and I'll end with this is this is the tip of the iceberg this is what people say to surveys and it's almost half already say they would do this what they would do when it's a viable option and when it's discovered that you know Elites however that's defined are doing it privately you you can rest assured that we're going to get a preference Cascade such that The Dominoes will fall very very quickly my prediction I I give a lot of stock talks on different to topics but my favorite one right now is called breaking the blank slate and one of the outcomes of that talk one of the the [1:01:43] predictions I make is that there's a lot of of lying right now and there's a lot of pluralistic ignorance lying about heritability people pretending it's not even real or I don't know anything about heritability intelligence it's all fake none of it's real the smarter you are paradoxically the more likely you are to deny the reality of intelligence or the heritability of it in fact we have data on that that's literally true the people who are closest to the truth on heritability scores for psychological traits are the people with the least amount of Education not intelligence education okay so that's an indoctrination effect and uh repeat what the Yeah so people who are closer [1:02:25] to what behavioral geneticists know about heritability scores are people with lower levels of Education I should add and with two or more children um rather than people who are highly educated and have no children why is that one is highly ideologically motivated the other is just like looking at reality and going damn one of my kids is kind of dumb and the other one's not or you know like one of them is like really aggressive and I'm so nice to him and he just won't shut up and he's like really mean and they're just like yeah I didn't do that it's just him like that's just how he was the mid whip meme the mid yeah the mid whip meme yeah you've got the I won't even repeat it um so anyway like the thesis is you know maybe I'm wrong about this I'd like to hear [1:03:06] what you guys have to say this is what I'll end on I think what'll happen is when when this stuff is more of a reality and some of us are already in companies doing it and more of those companies will be coming out really soon um and people are incentivized to learn about how how polygenic scores work I think they're going to talk more about it Elites are going to be privately doing it I can already name names but I won't do it even people who publicly denounce heritability or publicly denounce IVF are customers in many cases and what's going to happen is there's an increasing kind of dissonance between what certain Elites are saying and what people are doing privately and [1:03:46] understand privately until you know we get a Berlin wall type situation where everyone just goes yeah yeah yeah okay we know about that stuff other people are doing it I'm going to do it too and I think what's going to happen is these numbers even 5 years from now 10 years from now are going to look very very different so I'll end on that thank [1:04:14] you let's do some questions we do some questions right oh wait wait we're not ending you have questions right yeah yeah yeah but first we want to give you a um uh a make science grade again tacher beautiful all [Applause] righted all right did you have a question yeah go ahead so uh earlier thanks guys earlier in your presentation you contrasted uh G editing with genor screening based on the idea that for Gene editing you need to know the causal [1:04:55] impact genetic varant whereas with pgs don't but I guess my sense is that I think for pgs you also need to know which genetic varant are causal and which are not otherwise your up take the microphone here come come take the mic should I repeat that question yeah yeah take the take yeah guys if you want to go go but uh if you want to stay uh listen to the question yeah so my question was basically that earlier in Dr anomaly's presentation he contrasted Gene editing with polygenic Square screening based on the idea that for Gene editing you need to know the causal [1:05:36] impact of the variance in question whereas with pgs you may not need to know that information and my thinking was that you still need to know the causal impact for polygenic score-based um screening because otherwise your polygenic sore will simply pick up on environmental compounds and that could very well will be true even if you validate it out of sample because your out of sample um data set could also be containing those same environmental compounds sure okay good so you're also testing the limits of my knowledge because I'm not a statistical geneticist but uh um what I would say is that's almost true but not quite as far as I [1:06:17] can tell the reason is that so think of most complex traits we care about let's just say height or diabetes risk they're they're added right so it's lots of genetic variants adding just a little bit to the risk you know how you metabolize sugar whatever um you know if you miss a few genes or you get a few few wrong calls and you're selecting embryos you're still selecting among I hate the word natural but you know natural combinations of sperm and egg and you're not fundamentally really changing anything you're just kind of counting how much the risk is but I think there's at least a higher risk that if you're changing a variant that you're included in your polygenic risk score there's a [1:06:59] higher chance probably that you could do something that with it that you don't really understand the the full consequences of I could be wrong about that but that's my sense um yeah yeah I think like I agree that Gene editing is probably like requires perhaps more information but I think maybe where I might disagrees I think pgs space screening still requires understanding the causal impact imp okay let me let me just ask quick one and then we'll we'll move on um but we don't know a lot of a lot of causal information or so right now are you worried about polygenic screening in the absence of knowledge of cause of yes oh interesting okay yes so [1:07:41] like there is um a meta analysis of within sibling based genome wide Association studies which do estimate the causal impact of these variants on traits like IQ and they found that there is a pretty meaningful difference between um within sibling gws versus population level gws for Behavioral traits like IQ and so the risk is that if you estimate the polygenic scores without using sibling information then there then your polygenic score may be picking up on environmental biases instead of genetic variables this is a a great point and this is why sibling studies are better in my view for psychological traits than they are for [1:08:22] something like height something like that yeah I think that's exactly somebody uh IQ is highly dependent on different factors like uh shavasana is giving you uh 7 to 15 points in IQ jump just after like half an hour of this exercise or knowing models in knowing complex models that are not taught in schools uh about like everyday stuff everyday things is making you much much smarter than average beverage person so how how is this um uh uh how this uh [1:09:03] choice of causality between IQ and genes uh have what does it have to do with a a special knowledge that allow you to be more effective like like physical exercise nutrition model knowledge and is the question that you're skeptical that IQ is Meaningful or something yeah I mean not every education is uh Creed equal kind of if I know something about the yeah um yeah again not an expert here but I I highly recommend there's some good General books on this topic my favorite is like a two-hour read it's Stuart Richie's book just called [1:09:43] intelligence it's a only like 50 pages long it's like a pamphlet it's excellent just synthesizes 100 Years of knowledge about IQ tests and one of the things he starts with is spearman's idea he he wanted to figure out like how would I even test intelligence right like I don't even know where to start and so he just created complex puzzles for people and then he find that like almost any test that he could come up with ended up positively correlating with other tests and he he came up with this concept of G or general intelligence and that's basically the the kind of shared positive correlation across different kinds of tests and of course now there are different parts of this test and I'm not an IQ expert I've just read a lot of [1:10:24] the literature on it you know there's of course verbal reasoning spatial Etc there are different components and there is some positive overlap across those but of course some people have you know stronger skills in one Arena than in another Arena Etc I would just argue that um yeah among many Ordinary People IQ is underrated and among IQ enthusiasts it's overrated in many cases because you know I think personality traits matter a lot I think some of the correlates of IQ are doing more explaining than IQ like patience self-control that has it's not computational power it's not creativity it sometimes kind of goes along with it maybe it was selected for as a package [1:11:06] but so in that sense IQ is overrated but in the sense of if you think education's going to dramatically affect IQ you're just wrong about it it's just not true people have tried it it does have a modest effect but it's just simply not correct to say that you know education fundamentally transforms our abilities like if you spend enough time on physics with someone like they're GNA get good at physics I can I can attest that this is this is not the case um yeah yeah I just wanted to pick your brain sorry give him a polyenic score for reflexes I wanted to pick your brain about um the bankruptcy of 23 and me and what you think the whole impact tell me what you [1:11:47] think cuz I don't have thoughts on I don't know I I honestly don't have much of an opinion on it so I mean I think okay I'll just say a warning sign one thing you should all do if you're getting sequenc for whatever reason or sequencing embryos or anything is obviously pay attention to the security Protocols of of the company that you're working with um because yeah that's that's the main thing that kill 23 yeah next question yeah Careful by the way thank you this is all very interesting some of it is even reasonable I'm kidding uh it's tribute for for the day and uh a lot of things you said were based on the assumption [1:12:29] that parents know what's best for their kids but if my parents were to decide I think they would have chosen somebody else because I came up really fragile physically but the interesting thing is socially and economically I'm doing better than any relative I know specifically because of my poor health from the early age and I was very focused on seeking for resources and comfort in everyday life so the result is way way better and honestly I love my parents I love my family but I wouldn't trust them in choosing personal traits [1:13:09] for me because 100% they would have chosen somebody more obedient less rebellious someone easier to upbringing and probably they had zero knowledge about what kind of world world I would be living in and what traits will be beneficial for me like socially economically and otherwise so what are we going to do with that yeah I mean first of all yeah I I like that I some of my favorite thinkers in history had weirdnesses about them that led to their character So Adam Smith was clearly autistic well aspie anyway um a lot of the best scientists were highly [1:13:51] disagreeable didn't have good friends because they're kind of just but that also made them stick to their views even when everyone else was criticizing them for the wrong reasons my favorite philosopher nii was very sick and you know died of some mental illness maybe got it through syphilis we're not sure but but you know he was clearly sick and yeah I mean these are often opportunities to overcome challenges um nevertheless I have two general responses which is although diversity of traits is good and in many cases having deficits incentivizes us to try to overcome them and actually challenges or welcome you know this is from my friend Alan [1:14:32] Buchanan um who wrote a book on this used to teach at Duke with me years ago he sort of says look what's going to happen in an enhanced world is we're going to sort of be at higher plateaus where we're going to have even more challenges right so like genetic enhancement for example you know might extend lifespan or whatever but it's not going to solve the problem of of jealousy it's not going to solve the problem of we want to overcome goals set goals we're always going to be potentially sick or have all kinds of afflictions that they're going to be disappointed parents like that's part of being a parent is a lot of parents are disappointed and so you know one thing is I don't think any of that's going to go away it's part of the human condition and it might even be ramped up in some [1:15:13] ways the other point though is there is no we in the sense that unless you think the government should be making these decisions for you which I take it you don't think and I don't think you know this technology will be out there and one of the points that I made with arms races is people are going to be making decisions and then it'll be your parents decision like should I opt out of this and I think a lot will a lot will a lot of religious groups will just say I'm not doing this but a couple Generations down some will be like you know like maybe we should and others will still not do it and I think we're just going to get more and more Divergence as a result and that is unless you're willing to engage in massive coercion by governments [1:15:55] part of the human conditions I think this is sort of Promethean like we're a species we're you know we came from homo Havis you know the toolmaker we're Homo sapiens like the brain the brainy creature and like what makes us distinctive is we use our brains to make tools including cultural tools scientific tools and this is like the latest in a set of tools and that doesn't mean it's going to be good I think it probably will on net I'm reasonably confident but there will be some bad decisions that parents make and some bad outcomes collectively and we have like lots of these myths in western civilization that's a that's a metaphor for that right Flying Too Close to the sun um [1:16:35] Prometheus we've got all of these and I leave it to you to decide on net is this good I think it probably will be but great great questions and yeah um yeah thank you so much for your time uh just like a bit of a more simple maybe like slightly esoteric question um to what extent do you believe in the um the existence or the experience or the phenomenon of the Soul uh good question but I don't have a very good answer to that um yeah I'm I'm a this will be unpopular I guess but I'm a bit of a reductionist about that I'm [1:17:17] only now becoming more open-minded to it though in the last five or 10 years I was like a rabid atheist as a teenager right so kind of the obnoxious new atheist type um you know yeah like Dawkins I mean as a teenager Dawkins and nii and whatever just obviously stupid ridiculous all religion is yeah just manipulation I actually simulation arguments and things like that have made me more open-minded and the sheer Insanity of physics if you really understand it um you know why we can't answer questions like why is there something rather than nothing you know so I'm I'm open to Souls I just don't have deep thoughts about it so yeah [1:17:58] thank you all right go ahead rapid fire your turn go go ahead one two three go ahead go ahead okay three more yeah cool thank you um so my question is um have you thought about like the epigenetic concerns with IVF so for example like there's certain studies that say that babies born through IVF are higher risk of certain rare Cancers and that's just one thing that's quantifiable so I guess my question is a is is there even any truth to this and then B have you thought about like the implication of this like as a tech used at like the scale of an entire population great question um risk of IVF so I first of [1:18:38] all always have to say like I'm not an expert on this so do not trust me like anyone who says like they're an expert outside of their domain of expertise is like someone who shouldn't be listened to um I've looked at the studies people in my company have looked at the studies there's one giant problem with basically all of them almost all of them selection effects who is the population of people who traditionally have used IVF older and have different various medical problems and so as they say well I can't use that phrase It's too obnoxious but um you know whatever goes into a process comes out of a process let's put it that way Garb um so I mean this is this is a problem though right so like obviously if if male and female [1:19:20] age you know is partly a proxy for like mutation load you know if you're getting getting more mutations as du age and you know you're going to pass those on to your kids or if there's some other problem you're passing on the bad news so this is a problem for all studies on IVF for the first time in history people are doing IVF electively and freezing eggs when they're young and so on so we'll know later I strongly strongly doubt that there are serious issues there may be a couple of small small risks with IVF but anyone who tells you there are these risks you can't rely on those studies for the reason I mentioned and what you should always ask for is what's the causal mechanism like what would actually cause this maybe you'll [1:20:01] come up with one I'm open to it I don't think there is one right now it's kind of like with surrogacy are there is there evidence that like s going through surrogacy is going to be worse for your kid than I I don't claim to know the answer to that I don't think so though unless the surrogate is like drinking alcohol or whatever else um so that's my hi um a few related questions so so um so in some way we have stopped Evolution or St National selection because of the level of healthcare so so what does that mean to um right to the Future Generations are [1:20:43] we on average getting like weaker and Dumber um and related to another point you mentioned that um so so uh the age of having kids is getting older and older and you're saying even after 20 we're becoming start to degrade right so that means D kids um right so so what's the implication of that and that's the same time AI obviously is advancing at a great rate right so are we just going to right human are becoming dumber and we're going to rely more and more um yes I don't know yeah everyone's seen the movie Idiocracy is there truth [1:21:24] to that probably if demographic patterns idiocracy that's the the obviousy uh look I don't know but these things aren't set in stone so there are reproductive patterns we know what they look like you can you can look at the studies um but that doesn't mean in a thousand years or 100 years they'll stay that way I take it we're going to get much more genetic Divergence and as Tyler Cowan likes to say you're either going to be working with AI in the future or subjugated by people who use it or itself if it's a gii who are going to use you so um that's also another argument for paying attention to general intelligence I think it's um you know there are real risks to not doing that [1:22:05] in a world that increasingly rewards cognitive ability and that increasingly manipulates those with low cognitive ability so it's not inevitable but yeah it's a concern over long trajectories okay I guess there's one more and then one more and then we can talk later you guys yeah hi hang sorry people in the back we can hear are you talking almost done um you mentioned that obviously you know expecting parents as they are going through genetic selection they're going to be a little more selfish they're going to select for genes and their embryos that they want to have in their child whether that's height intelligence and those [1:22:45] incentives for what is good for a child you want are not going to necessarily align for what is good for society so and obviously the US is a little behind other countries I'm so curious you know so where do that responsibility lie in terms of how we can make that framework or how we think about these decisions are there countries are there other countries or other governing bodies that have done a good job um thinking ahead of hey here are the considerations we want to make um because obviously is it does it lay with the parents does it lay with the the clinical facilities the government like what are the things that we're not really thinking about in terms of like future planning ahead yeah good I mean this this is uh the problem governments are mostly not [1:23:27] thinking about it I think Singapore and the US will be among the at the Forefront here for various reasons um the thing that I would worry about and I talk about it in Chapter 2 of my book is uh moral dispositions so you know there are personality traits and moral dispositions we have some people call us an evolutionary Game Theory strong reciprocators um We're Not Mere reciprocators bacteria do that like they'll trade favors with each other for selfish interests right like I'll sacrifice something now so that I get a bigger payoff later yeah we do that of course but what's what's distinctive about most people other than Psychopaths and some other Misfits is that we [1:24:09] actually take pleasure to some extent in contributing voluntarily to public goods um we have a we have a set of moral emotions we feel pride in it we feel guilty if we don't contribute to Collective collectively good Endeavors and so on and um I think that people have mixed incentives like they might want their kid to be for example a little less empathetic than average if if other people are choosing more empathy or some sort of you might call it parasitic strategies parasitic in the game theoretic sense so I would worry a little bit about that but I don't trust governments to control it I think that social norms again are where it's at and I don't know [1:24:51] here's a crazy solution that I don't know what I think about but maybe people will be publicly posting you know the kinds of endowments they chose or whatever right or how they selected um either for fun or to participate in something speaking of 23 and me like trade your data in response for in exchange for something interesting like ancestry maybe there will be things like this where we see like what people are choosing and we shame people you know for for choosing in socially you know suboptimal ways guilt and shame are like super important moral emotions that Darwin spent a lot of time thinking about and now in kind of you know modern liberal societies we we actually [1:25:32] underutilize them we think like shame it's just about you shouldn't shame people it's of course you shame people if they engage in antisocial Behavior it's like the best thing you could do you're morally required to shame people you're actually a selfish brat if you don't do it um now how do we apply that to the reproductive realm it's super complicated but I still think that we should we should rely on these evolved moral tions and then social norms which tend to tra our moral emotions rather than um trying to aggregate it in a forceful way through through governments or something so is that imperfect yes but I don't know what the alternative is so yeah good question thanks [Applause] [1:26:21] guys you had one last question oh yeah actually I was about to I went to the B that was the only the only thing I cared about well TR Trove of data see [Music] All Right Touch The Rock dude good job good job [Music] [1:27:24] from uh Twitter yeah Twitter tter I get back to you but we should don't yeah um just like I'm from crypto cre awesome well yeah thanks for joining yeah we have a lot [Applause] [Music] anyway I'll you than yeah on the [Music] website hey um I here thank you for hting it was awesome yeah interested [Music] [Music] [Applause] [1:29:09] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Music] than yeah [Music] [Music] I [Music] [Music] [Applause] got be [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Music] get [1:32:03] world [Music] my [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Music] she [Music] [Music] that's [Music] [Music] why like [Music] w [Music] [1:35:51] I said yeah definitely actually want really honestly I can't wait doctor be so SI that's I have much more to say I might I might sneak out this is cool I like this like the lighting in here it's pretty dope I like how everybody's like support like this is so cool look at thisen like I don't even know what the that is like let me take it down yeah everyone's willing something every like I got [Music] [1:36:32] this but yeah um I don't know the more see this like trying to figure out how to get stuff I was trying to get done done just like the sooner you start the sooner sooner you get it done like people eat it up you what youat up yeah I know got to get some oh well you going to do it yeah I know I know lot a lot yeah and you got a team of people behind you I know I just got a like you can do it you can do it you're [1:37:13] creative you're amazing I know like our I know I do it do it I know it's a being afraid of your own potential know done that she's still there so I I can't even I feel he's too far away from the [Music] good [1:38:09] [Music] [Music] [Music] pictures Drive [1:38:38] quickly that was awesome yeah do more next time a lot ofday I feel like it's just kind of we're we're the old people now you know it's like I've been fing out it's like every time I talk about something that happened in college I'm like yeah that was about 10 years ago I feel like I hit nerd and I was like I don't care anymore I'm fine like whatever is going to Happ is going to happen yeah no that's how I my 29th birthday it'sing out yeah so nice to meet you I'll catch you the next one [1:39:19] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Music] by [1:39:59] um so are you making a real face did you put it in the bag the thing [1:40:14] [Music] [1:40:24] [Music] [Music] [Music] got [Music] it oh sure h [1:41:16] [Music] now [Music] [Music] [Music] [1:41:59] [Music] [Music] [Music] know [Music] [Music] [1:42:46] somewhere [Music] [Music] [Music] of these that I can't find theu Ro [1:43:38] [Music] [Music] [Music] by way sharing [Music] [Music] [1:44:38] you [Music] [Music] have [Applause] [Music] [Music] [Music] [1:45:55] that's my [1:46:09] [Music] [Music] let [1:46:32] [Music] [Music] f [Music] [1:47:16] [Music] [Music] [Music] look