Talk & transcript
Bioelectricity
Professor Michael Levin
Transcript
Download textAutomatically generated transcript. May contain errors. Select a timestamp to watch that moment on YouTube.
okay everyone
everyone El there's a um guys we're going to start welcome hello is working join test one two admit okay there we go um guys uh there's plenty of room over here so squeeze in that way to the right your left your right sorry um um come on play space play Space don't be shy say hello to your neighbor um do you guys want to no anyone else okay well first off um thank you
guys all for coming uh how many of you know why you're here okay good how many of you know what like decentralized science is at all yes some people there some people okay yeah this is decentral this is centralized science um in this vicinity here um how many of you have been to like a d NC event before oh wow so many people we have a lot of return desires we're going to issue a token at some point which will be cool like a d NYC token so you can memorialize your um being on the chain um cool um well without further let's just do a quick a quick picture just um
we'll do one okay smile smile smile smile smile smile will go on the on the Twitter and such okay oh my gosh I think this might be one of our largest ones um and then we just do one more oh so we're going to do it slightly differently this time so Michael Levan is going to speak first how many of you have seen Michael Levan on like a on one of his talks already like when we were when see wow that's a lot of people okay one more um when when I was like promoting this event um we got a lot of DMS who said like he's my
favorite speaker can you hear us Michael yeah I can okay good um he said like he was one he was this is one of his favorite of a couple people messaged me saying like Michael 11 is one of our favorite um uh Tech speakers that they've ever seen so that was that was that was just totally uh cool um can you see the audience here Michael yeah 80 people it's great um and then um what else did I want to say um there's last thing oh yeah if you guys like post us on uh on Twitter or on Instagram uh we'd be forever grateful it helps to spread the word it helps to decentralize science um it helps to get the word out so um I'm
going to let Michael speak I'm just going to say one thing if you like decentralized science um we started a decentralized science company I'll talk more about it in the second but I know some people are going to go but I just want to say um if you're looking for a job um we're hiring to do like a decentralized science platform so if this is interesting to you we have an in-person office in New York City we're looking to hire Community managers developers business people um we pay really really well and we have a great office and a great team and we're looking to grow so um if you're interested in this and you're interested in decentralized science maybe you're an angry academic maybe you're looking to change the world um maybe you're looking
to see something better we'll do this but I just want to get that before and we I'll do a little talk on uh what is decentralized science after um Professor 11 speaks so um without further Ado uh Professor 11 is a professor at un tus University super renowned in his field on for his work on bioelectricity which was one I first first heard about it I was amazed and uh I'll let you take it from here yeah thanks so much let's give a round of applause thank you so much for the invitation uh and that very kind introduction and thanks for letting me share some ideas with you so let me uh let's see I'm to figure out how to share
our screen here all right uh so I'm going to turn on my slides and when I do I will not be able to see you so if anything goes wrong just please uh somebody somebody speak up all right here we go okay so uh what I'd like to talk about today is uh the field of diverse intelligence and specifically the kind of uh cognitive processes that go on in your body and what this means for various other issues uh you can find all the primary work like the primary papers data set software everything at this site and uh you can sign up for announcements and uh get some uh some thoughts uh sort of beyond what I what I can say peerreview Publications you could get that at my
blog here so uh there's there's four things I'd like to talk about today first of all I'm going to talk a little bit about what I mean by diverse or unconventional intelligence I will give you some examples of such uh looking at bioelectricity and how it functions as a kind of cognitive glue that binds the cells in your body into a kind of collective intelligence and this collective intelligence solves problems in anatomical space also known as morphos space uh we'll talk about some biomedical applications that result from thinking in this in these kinds of ways and towards the end we're going to touch on some issues about the future and and what I think it means for all of us so uh this is a well-known classic painting
it's called um Adam is naming the animals in the Garden of Eden and I I find this very interesting because I think there's one uh profoundly wrong aspect of this old story and also there's one very deep aspect that I think is is really is really right on the money that we have to U absorb um part that's that I think is wrong here is that uh this gives you the idea that these animals are discreet natural kinds right you look at this and you say okay I know what all these animals are there's a there's a finite discrete set of individual animals with specific shapes and specific behaviors and Adam uh is actually different than than all of them he's he's special and so I think th those two things we going to have to blow up in the next couple of decades that that that will uh I think that's
going to disappear uh the part that I think this is that's really deep here is that in this old biblical story uh it was actually Adam's job to name the animals the Angels couldn't do it God couldn't do it Adam was the one who was supposed to name the animals and I think that's for two reasons one is that he's the one that's going to have to live with them and the other is that in these old kind of mystical Traditions uh naming something or or knowing the name of the the real name of something means that you've understood its true nature and that that understanding is supposed to give you power over that thing right so knowing the name of something is really deep deep and I think this is this is important because we are all going to have to name in this in this kind of meaning we're going to have to
name a whole uh large set of Novel beings that have never been here before with whom we are going to share our world and I think that's that's really important so uh you no doubt have read um all kinds of uh uh works of of of philosophy and and other more modern maybe stories about the difference between humans and maybe machines and other things and what people typically have in mind when they say those things is is this kind of uh this this typical adult modern human that has this like agential special glow about them but we've known now for a really long time that both uh on an evolutionary time scale and also a developmental time scale uh there is actually a Continuum
of bodies and we'll get back to this towards the end of the talk but actually this form has very slowly and gradually evolved from all these other forms and and originally a unicellular microbial ancestor and the same thing is true during your lifetime so whatever properties this kind of uh being has and so memory uh true goals preferences understanding uh moral worth um responsibility and so on we really as as scientists and philosophers we really ow some a story about how that arises you know where in this Continuum does that actually show up and is it better to think about that as a kind of discreet thing you know you have it or you don't have it or what I think uh is that it's
actually a Continuum the right question is what kind and how much and so I've been working on a on a framework uh to enable us to uh recognize create and ethically relate to a really diverse set of intelligences that are very different from the kinds of things that we usually uh recognize as intelligences so Apes Birds maybe an octopus or a whale or something but but all kinds of other creatures Colonial organisms and swarms like beehives and ant colonies uh synthetic bi olog engineered new life forms AIS whether robotic or purely software and maybe at some point aliens some point at some point maybe we find some exobiological life so so we we need
to be able to talk about all of these things simultaneously what what do they all have in common uh and and I'm I'm not the first person to try for a framework like this this is a 1943 weer of Rosen Bluth and Bigalow tried for a scale that goes all the way from passive matter so basically simple passive materials all the way up through uh these kinds of different stages to the kind of complex second order metacognition that that that humans have where they they can think about themselves and they know that they know things and and and so on so uh what we need is a is a story of scaling how do how do very simple information processing uh kinds of Acts become minds and whatever framework that we come up
with it has to move experimental or forward it can't just be philosophy it needs to actually give us new capabilities for example new biom medicine um and it also Al has to uh enhance ethics it has to enhance our ability to uh understand our world and uh and and relate to it with the appropriate kind of compassion so the fundamental fact is that all of us uh take this journey we've we've all made this journey from what people call just physics and I really hate that term but people use it um as a as an unfertilized oite you you were once all all of us were once a little blob of chemicals and when people look at that blob they say okay well this is uh just a physical chemical system it obeys the laws of
chemistry there is no there is no mind here just a bunch of chemicals but at some point slowly and gradually uh it turns into one of these amazing kinds of creatures or even something like this here's Renee deart who was fond of saying that um he was not a machine and um uh and uh you know had special special properties and so that's fine but we need to really then tell a story of where does that happen and developmental biology offers absolutely no place where you can draw a bright line and say okay before that it was just a bunch of chemicals doing the things that chemicals do but now bang now now now it's a real being with a real mind and preferences and goals and so on uh there is no spot like that in developmental biology so so we really need to understand the scaling this well
at least okay so that's so that's a little that that should be if you take that on uh to you know really really understand that it should be a little disturbing um but at least we're a true unified intelligence right we're not like an ant colony which people do describe ants and thermites as a a kind of collective intelligence but but we're not like that right like we are a centralized unified mind you know we have a we have a brain and everything well uh Rene dekart thought so and in particular he was fond of the pineal gland because there's only one of them in the brain and he felt that our unified human intelligence should have one spot in the brain that isn't duplicated the way that other structures are but uh if he had access to microscopes he would have discovered
that actually there isn't one of anything because in the pineal gland this is what it looks like there are uh huge numbers of individual cells and if he had really good microscopy inside each one of those cells he would see this this is what's actually inside all of this stuff is inside every cell so actually all of us are collective intelligences even even we no no no less than ant colonies and um beehives and flocks of birds We Are All Made of parts and in fact I think all intelligence is collective intelligence in fact for us th this is the sort of thing we're made of now this happens to be a free living organism known as the lacr Maria uh but it's a single cell and you can see the amazing competency it has at its local
scale so with respect to single cell events it handles all of its anatomical needs its metabolic needs its physiological needs uh no brain no nervous system no stem cells uh everything is handled by this amazing little organism and we we are a large Collective of cells that have enormous competencies in different spaces and so if you look at our structure structure not only are we a a set of nested dolls consisting of various chemicals and subcellular components and then tissues and organs and organisms and then of course societies and swarms not only structurally are we a collection of uh these hierarchical
levels but actually each of these has its own competency its own intelligence its own problem solving capacity so in other kinds of spaces not just in three-dimensional space that we're used to such as for example when mice run mazes and so on but in other spaces the space of physiological States the space of all possible types of gene expression the space of all possible anatomical configurations in all of these spaces the different uh levels of your body structure are solving problems pursuing goals storing and um utilizing memories uh and navigating those spaces with great Ingenuity that uh that amazing architecture this multiscale competency
competency architecture which currently our technology you know Robotics and uh and and our typical AIS don't use anything like that um no reason why we couldn't but but no one's done it yet but biology uses this amazing multiscale architecture and allows some truly astounding capabilities for living forms I'm going to show you a couple of interesting examples um one of the things that biology can do uh is uh have a kind of uh you could almost call it a kind of beginner's mind uh concept where uh it doesn't really make Evolution doesn't just make uh organisms that are solutions to specific problems it actually makes problemsolving machines that come into the world with massive
plasticity ready to take on novel configurations so what you're looking at here is a tadpole here's the uh here's the mouth here are the nostrils here's the brain here's the tail this thing is the gut and what you'll notice here is that what's happening here is that there are no two there are no eyes in the primary location where the eyes go uh but there is an eye that we induced on the T and what you see is that these animals when you was we built this machine to train these tat balls in a visual task and what you find out is that they can see perfectly well and this eye which is now located on their tails uh doesn't connect to the brain here's the here's the optic nerve sometimes it connects to the spinal cord like this sometimes to nothing at all and they do very well in
visual assays so just think about what this means for millions of years this this uh brain was um uh perfectly perfectly adapted to take visual input right here from from from the eyes next to it and now you've got this weird itchy patch of tissue on your back that's providing some sort of electrical signal onto your spinal cord why doesn't it take uh many rounds of evolutionary adaptation you know mutation selection for this to work it works right out of the box first time first time you do it it it doesn't require any more evolutionary cycles and that's because this this this kind of creature as all of us has has massive uh plasticity uh it uh there there are there are lots of
other interesting features for example this these are plenaria these are flat worms and what's interesting about these guys is that they are uh incredibly regenerative so you can cut them into many pieces each piece will regenerate and become a perfect tiny little worm now one thing that James McConnell discovered in the 60s and he got a lot of flak for it but um he was actually right we repeated his work using modern um automated methods in 2013 and he was he was completely right uh that if you train a planarian for example to feed on these little bumpy um these little bumpy circles and uh then you amputate their head including their brain and you get this tail left here the tail sits there doesn't do much of anything for the next eight days doesn't have a doesn't have
any Behavior but what it does do is it grows back a new brain and as it grows back in your brain you then can test these animals and you find out that they've remembered the original information so not only is the anatomy regenerated but so are the memories and actually whatever I mean presumably they're stored in a tail somewhere we don't know where um and kind of distributed throughout the body and then they are imprinted onto the new brain as the brain develops so that they can uh demonstrate Behavior so the movement of information through the body right you're seeing here simultaneously the ability to restore anatomical structures so anatomical memories but also behavioral memories and these things are linked and one of the most um remarkable examples is this
um these are these are caterpillars and they have a particular brain suitable for crawling around using the soft body architecture uh in a two-dimensional world and uh they need to turn into this this is a flying hard body kind of a um being that uh has a completely different life and it has a different brain uh because of that in order to do this it basically uh destroys most of the brain during metamorphosis so many of the cells are killed the connections are broken and it refactors into a new brain but what has been found is that if you train these caterpillars on a particular task uh the butterflies or moths results still remember so there are two fascinating things here not only is it
amazing to ask where is the information that it's uh robust to this incredible refactoring of the memory medium we don't have any technology like that if you start shuffling around uh the the pieces of your memory chips inside your computer nothing nothing's going to work but um but not not only not only is the memory robust you actually if you think about it you realize that you actually can't just store the information you have to completely interpreted for a new context for example if you teach these caterpillars to uh eat leaves when you provide a certain color stimulus those specific memories are totally useless to the butterfly because butterflies don't eat leaves and they don't move around the way the caterpillars do they have to reinterpret those memories in a brand
new way suitable for this creature in its three-dimensional new life so uh so so during these kind of Transformations you see that memory biological memory isn't just stored it's actually actively creatively reinterpreted these memory engrams that are made are reinterpreted for their new lifetime so uh lots of fascinating things to be said about behavioral memories and so on but I want to spend a few minutes talking about uh what we study which is primarily anatomical memories so so let's think about this this is this is a cross-section through the human body so look at this uh incredible complexity of all the organs in the Torso so everything is where it needs to be in the right place the right you know the right direction next to the right thing
uh almost all of the time where does this pattern come from because we start Life as a collection of blastam and eventually these cells build something like this where is that pattern uh people might be tempted to say DNA but we can read genomes now and we know that is not what is in the genome what's in the genome are specifications of proteins the tiny molecular Hardware that every cell gets to have but this structure is the uh outcome of the uh phys the physiological software that these cells are executing and so we this information is no more in the genome than is the actual structure of the of the of the colony of you know ants and
termites or the specific structure of a of a spider web uh in the DNA of the spider so we have to really understand okay uh how do the cells know what to make how do they know when to stop uh if something is damaged how do we convince them to repair it and actually which I'll show you a little bit towards the end what what else is that Hardware willing to do what what else can it build what what can we make from the exact same cells with the exact same DNA and I like to think of kind of the endgame of our field here as as this someday you're going to be able to sit down in front of a computer and use something called an anatomical compiler what's going to happen here is that you will draw uh the animal plant or biobot
organoid whatever uh that you want at the level of anatomy not at the level of genetic circuits or anything like that but the actual anatomy and what the system ought to be able to do is compile down that anatomical description into a uh specific uh set of stimuli that have to be given to cells to build exactly what you want to build now the Practical reason we need to we need something like this is because imagine if you had the ability to tell groups of cells what to build you would do away with birth defects uh you would be able to heal and regenerate after traumatic injury you could reprogram cancer you could stop and reverse aging you can stop degenerative disease all of these things all of these major problems of biom medicine would go away if we understood
how to get a group of cells to build exactly what we want them to build now the key here is that this device uh is not a 3D printer which is not about micromanaging cells and trying to print body structures it's a Communications device it's a way to translate your anatomical specification what it is that you're looking for into the goal states that these cells are accessing when they build some particular structure now I'll tell you that uh we don't have anything remotely like this and uh we can only do this in in a in a few individual cases and and the reason is is that here's here's where uh current state-of-the-art is we're very good at manipulating cells and molecules uh processing information like this about which genes interact with which other genes which proteins
attached together and so on but we're really a long way away from what we really want which is complete control of large scale Form and Function somebody is missing a limb we ought to be able to tell those cells to rebuild so so why is that and I think it's because uh molecular medicine has been largely stuck where computer science was in the 1940s and 50s this is what it looks like uh that programming a computer used to be used to look like uh you can see what she's doing she's interacting with the hardware she's rewiring the machine to get it to do something and you would all laugh if I told you that on your laptops um nowadays if you wanted to go from Microsoft Word to photoshop you would have to get out your soldering iron and start rewiring yeah the whole the whole
uh point of uh what we've learned in uh in computer science and information technology over the years is that if your Hardware is good enough and the biological Hardware is definitely good enough uh what you have here is a reprogrammable medium that is much better off controlled by communication by signals by stimuli and this is what we're still missing to a large degree in biom medicine uh we understand the hardware more or less we really have only begun to scratch the surface of the software the the software of Life the intelligence that's inherent in every uh layer of of our of our body systems I going to show you a couple of examples of this well first of all um we all know that development is reliable so most of
the time the egg will gives rise to a bunch of cells that build the correct human target morphology but it's not just about um emergent complexity or reliability it's actually much more interesting than that because if you start cutting early uh embryos into pieces this is naturally how you get twins and triplets and quadruplets you don't get half bodies you get perfectly normal monozygotic Twins and various multiples and this means that in this anatomical space where you go from different starting States you know here's one here's one from different starting States all of them can navigate that space to a particular Ensemble of goal States corresponding to valid human anatomies and sometimes they can they can actually um avoid all kinds of local
Minima meaning perturbations that you that you give them along the way they can solve problems and get where they need to go this is Jame William james' definition of intelligence the ability to get to the same End by different means this is what I mean by uh different types of intelligence by navigating these problem spaces now some animals can do this throughout their lifespan so here is an axotal and these amphibians uh can regenerate their eyes their jaws their tails uh their limbs portions of the heart and brain and what that looks like is when they bite each other's legs off no matter where that occurs whatever the piece uh is uh is is remaining these cells will build exactly what's needed no more no less to make a
perfect salamander Limb and and then they stop and that's the most amazing thing about regeneration is that it knows when to stop and so this this this idea that you have a particular structure and when you deviate from that structure the cells work really hard to get back to uh that same region of anatomical space and then they know that they've got there and they know that that's their that's their goal and then they stop so that is a kind of anatomical homeostasis it's the same thing that um your thermostat does at home where you set a set point and when the temperature goes off the system will work hard to get you back to that that goal State and then it stops okay and by the way uh this is not just this kind of regeneration is not just for amphibians the human liver is highly regenerative
um even the ancient Greeks knew that I have no idea how they knew that but they did uh deer every year will regenerate huge amounts of bone and vasculature and inovation when they regrow their antlers up to a centimeter and a half of new uh new bone per day they grow and um and and and even human children can regenerate their fingertips so so if you just keep it clean uh then these kind of amputations and kids end up with a very very nice cosmetic outcome so but we're of course not as good as as salamanders or plarium so um I want to show you uh just kind of one of my favorite examples to tr really try to bring home just how much uh how much how much amazing creative problem solving these systems
have this is a schematic of a cross-section through a kidney tubule of a of a salamander and what you see here is that about eight to 10 cells work together to build the structure and then they leave a lumen in the middle through which the fluid has to go one thing you can do is you can force these cells early on to have way more genetic material than they should and when that happens the nuclei gets get bigger and the cells get bigger to accommodate when that happens the the resulting new is actually exactly the same size because the cells adjust fewer of these larger cells are now getting together to make exactly the same Lumen the most amazing thing happens when you make these cells truly gigantic then it uses a completely different molecular mechanisms such that
only one cell wraps around itself leaving a hole in the middle and still gives you the exact same structure so think of what this means if you're a a nude coming into the world you don't know how many copies of your genetic material you're going to have you don't know how big your cells are going to be you don't know how many cells you're going to have you have to figure out you have to use all the tools that your disposal all the molecular mechanisms that you have to solve this problem how do I get from being an egg to being an adult uh despite all these Novelties you can't you can't count on anything you can't assume that your evolutionary history has has prepared you for knowing what to do and the same thing happens in the transition from uh from frog from TPO to frog you know they have to they have to rearrange their whole face but
uh these Picasso tadpoles which have the organs in abnormal locations so the eyes on the back of the head the mouth is off to the side these guys still make quite normal frogs because all of these organs will move in unnatural paths to get to where they need to go to look like a good frog and then they stop so so this is uh this this means that genetics does not actually give you some kind of hardwired um automatic process that just goes in the in the same direction it uh what it what it does encode is a machine that can do an error minimization scheme it can actually uh get to where it needs to go despite all sorts of things going wrong so now this raises an obvious question how does it know what's right how do these things know what a correct
frog face looks like so we've been studying this and um you know the uh sort of uncontroversial example of collections of cells storing a goal state for behavior is what happens in the brain so the way it works in the brain is that you have these these electrical networks of cells that communicate electrically uh via ions that go in and out of these little ion channels and then they pass through these electrical synapses and the computations that are processed by that Network result in the software that we see as Behavior so basically here um this is a zebra a living zebra fish brain that uh the commitment of Neuroscience is that if we knew how to decode all of this uh
electrophysiological activity we could read out the thoughts the memories the goal States the the the competencies of this of this animal well it turns out that this is not anything special to or unique to brains uh every cell in your body has these ion channels most cells have electrical connections to their neighbors and uh evolution discovered that these electrical networks were good for processing information really long time ago back around the beginning of bacterial biofilms actually long before multicellularity or brains or nerves or anything like that so then one can ask well if the electrical networks of the brain think about moving you through three-dimensional space what do the
electrical networks of the body think about what were these cells thinking about before there were brains and what we've been studying is this idea that what they're thinking about is how to navigate anatomical space they're thinking about how to get from uh whatever situation they happen to be in whether a normal egg or some kind of perturbed system into the right kind of body for the environment in which they find themselves so in order to do this we've developed some uh some interesting techniques using voltage sensitive fluorescent dies to really uh literally read the mind of the body to see all the electrical conversations that cells are having with each other so these are not computer models these are real you know these are some cells uh and uh and this is an early frog embryo and the colors
are signals from a voltage reporter die that enables us to see what all the electrical states are we are we are reading it we then have all these computer models that we use to try to understand and try to decode what is what what are the memories here and I'm going to show you some um some examples um this is an early frog embryo putting its face together uh it's quite Dynamic but but here's one frame from that video and you can see the the bi electric pattern here we call this the electric face because it basically looks like a face here's here's where it knows the eye needs to go here's where the mouth needs to go some other organs out here this is uh where the organs are going to be in the future this is a pre pattern
that it uses to figure out where to put all the crano facial organs now it's not just cells within an embryo that communicate but actually individual embryos communicate with each other so you can see what's happening here in the group that when this guy sets off a wave uh they all they all feel it and here are a bunch of cells where you can see there's some uh some some neural firing here but there are also some some lots of activity in these non- neural cells okay so uh this this the these are pretty ubiquitous these electrical networks are pretty ubiquitous now observing these amazing uh bioelectrical signals is uh is is is fun and everything but uh you don't know that the patterns mean anything unless you can functionally alter them you alter them and you see what happens so we've
developed tools uh mostly uh borrowed from from neuroscience and I think one of the lessons we're learning is that Neuroscience is really not about neurons at all the deep lessons of Neuroscience tell us about all cells and and and and about intelligence more broadly and what we do is uh we change these b electrical patterns we don't use there there are no electrodes uh there are no magnets no waves no frequencies no electromagnetic radiation what we do is we hack the normal interface that cells are using to hack each other's Behavior which is the ion channels on their surface and the Gap Junctions that they use to exchange electrical signals this is what we target so we control how cells communicate with each other electrically and when you do this you can do some
really cool things for example by injecting some RNA and coding a potassium Channel which changes the voltage of the cells we can induce a little spot in the embrio that looks just like that eye spot in that electric face and when you do that somewhere else for example in cells that are going to become gut uh what you've just done is tell these cells build an eye here you have not uh said anything about how the eye should form what are the components of an eye you haven't said anything to the stem cell or to the specific um genes inside of each one you talking to the collective uh to the collective intelligence of cells that are trying to navigate morphospace and what you've said is go to the region that
corresponds to making an eye and they know how to do this uh here are all the internal or um tissues of the of these eyes so lens retina optic Nerf all that and they even have some other some other cool properties that you find in other Collective intelligences like ANS which is that so so here's here's a lens sitting out the flank of a tadpole somewhere if you inject just a few cells not enough to really make a whole eye so the blue ones are the ones we injected what they will do is recruit their neighbors they tell their neighbors that hey you need to participate with us in making this eye and they and they instruct them so we instruct these cells you should make an eye they then uh instruct their neighbors so all of these competencies knowing how to make an eye knowing how many cells there are and
recruiting new cells if they need to uh all of this is built in it's part of the competency of the material that we're dealing dealing with and um we have extended this towards some um regenerative applications there are huge numbers of people living with limb and organ loss uh every day um we need Therapeutics that are not just going to be for wound healing but actually to uh regenerate whole organs and we can see here that uh what happens here normally frogs unlike salamanders do not regenerate their legs but we've come up with a cocktail that uh triggers uh not only pro- regenerative gene expression here but actually uh within 45 days you've already got some some some toes and the toenail but in
our latest experiments what happens is that the treatment itself the the bi electric cocktail is applied for about 24 hours after that you get a year and a half of leg growth in the adult frog you don't touch it at all during that time this is not about micromanaging this is not about controlling the stem cells or 3D printing anything this is about telling the cells very early on go down the leg regeneration path not the scarring path and So eventually you get a quite nice leg that touch sensitive and motile um we are in the process of moving this to mammals now uh I should say that I have to do disclosure here because Dave Kaplan and I have a have a company um whose job it is to try to move this into into Mamon models and
hopefully patients and David's group makes these wearable bioreactors that apply the uh the Ion channel drug um payload and um uh come back to the planaria for a moment because there's something really interesting here about uh how we reprogram these pattern memories I want to again show you the the the plasticity of the material that we're dealing with so here are the here are the planaria that um I was telling you about some amazing properties that we can talk about um if people have questions as far as cancer resistance immortality I mean these guys literally don't seem to age and so on but one of the things that we need to understand is when uh if they were to uh be chopped into three pieces so you got this middle
fragment here uh it 100% of the time it grows one head and one tail and you get a normal planarian so now the question is how does it know how does this thing know how many heads it's supposed to have and where the heads are supposed to be so it turns out that there's an electrical circuit that controls this we've characterized that circuit and we've learned to rewrite it so that what happens here is that this bioelectrical pattern so this is the memory this is literally the memory of the collective intelligence of the body as far as how many heads it's supposed to have in here one head so what we can do is we can change that pattern to say know two heads and when you do that in this animal after you amputate then it goes ahead and makes a two-headed animal this isn't Photoshop or AI or anything like
that these are real animals and this bioelectric pattern is not a map of this two-headed guy this pattern is the pattern that we uh uh in in incepted into this one headed normal worm it's got It's anatomically normal the molecular gene expression is normal you know here here's where the the head genes are uh but it has a different internal representation of what a correct planarian should look like we've Rewritten the goal the target state so this is not micromanaging the cells this is changing the mind of this collective intelligence as far as what I should do if I get injured in the future so it's really a counterfactual memory and one planarian body can store a normal
planarian body can store at least one of two possible representations of what what a normal worb should look like and in fact one of the remark one of the most remarkable things is that uh once once you do that uh the memory stays uh two-headed worms cut again and again in plain water will continue to uh regenerate as two-headed animals it's permanent even though there's nothing wrong with the genetics of this animal we have not touched the genome there are no trans genes uh this is this is purely bi electrical I showed you exactly where and where the electrical memory is stored and how we can see it and here are the um here are these two-headed two-headed worms and not only can we can we change the number of heads but we can
actually change the shape of the head to that of other species so the shape of the head can of this triangle species can become flat like a Pina it can become round like an S mediterrania shape of the brain changes like these other species the shape of the position of the stem cells does so in this anatomical morphos space where you have attractors you have these deep attractors corresponding to other species they live there naturally but you can get a different species such as this guy to visit these other attractors uh because because it's so reprogrammable not only that you can take it further and uh find regions of morphospace uh where you know machine learning folks would call this a latent morphos space
where you can make you can make you can build things that are not normal PL area at all things that are spiky or a cylindrical or combinations like this so what I'm showing you is that the body is incredibly plastic it's reprogrammable at the level of physiology not necessarily uh the genetically uh the specified Hardware but we are not the only bioengineers that can hack this kind of morphogenetic navigation this is what you normally see uh acorns make something like this and you kind of get this is extremely reliable this happens so often that you get the idea that okay well the oak genome just knows how to do this this is what the oak genome knows how to do that is what they do every single time but there's this amazing
bioengineer this wasp and it's a parasite and what the parasite does is uh use using some kind of chemicals that are still poor like poorly understood uh it basically hacks the surrounding plant cells to build something completely different would you have any idea that these flat uh the nice flat green leaves with a with a normal genome a completely normal genome were capable of building something as crazy as this we'd have no idea and people talk about developmental constraints I I don't I don't you know there's a lot of constraints in our in our thinking about the process but I I'm not sure we understand morphogenetic constraints at all I think they're much broader than than people think and this this kind of uh this kind of hacking is ubiquitous in biology and we are just
learning to do it and with this this this notion of uh what what lies beyond the normal morphology you know repair repair of the uh of the of the typical Anatomy but what's beyond that I want to show you uh this this basically this last example uh which is which is this if I showed you this little little organism and I would ask you to guess what this is you might say we've we've uh found this at the bottom of a pond somewhere it's some kind of primitive uh primitive you know microorganism if you were to sequence the Genome of this what you would get is 100% Homo sapiens this is we call these anthr robots they are made of adult patient tracheal epithelia so adult often elderly patients donate
their their tracheal cells we have a protocol that lets these cells reboot their uh multicellularity and live an entirely New Life uh that has new uh shapes and behaviors they look nothing like um any stage of of of human development and uh one of the unique things that they know how to do which is really um shockingly uh shocking and surprising is that they know how to heal neural wounds so if you if you put down some human neurons in the dish and you put a big scratch through them uh these these anthr robots will sit down in this kind of like superbot cluster and what you'll see when you lift them up four days later what they've done is they've taken the two sides of the neural wound and they and they knit them together who
who who would have ever thought that your tracheal cells which sit there quietly for decades in your Airway uh actually have given the opportunity make a multi little creature that runs around on its own um and has and has lots of interesting abilities such as for example uh healing neural wounds and so this one of the biomedical aspects of this is that this is a personalized medicine where cells from your own body not genetically modified there's no reason to genetically modify them uh can be used to heal your own body uh from with and and and no need for for example immune suppression because they're your own cells they're not some sort of heterologous cell type so this kind of agential biomedical intervention these
these kind of biobots made from your own cells to heal uh are I think a huge potential application for the future so um the last thing the last thing I'll just say is that you know not not only do we have these uh two contina that remind us that we are on an unbroken slow uh Continuum with all kinds of other unusual forms including cells and whatever you say about adult humans you have to ask what what can you say about some of these other intermediate forms but also there's another Continuum here which consists of now rational changes that are made U for uh various kinds of modifications and augmentations so both technological and purely biological uh I
think that the future belongs to a kind of freedom of embodiment I think that uh this standard form that Evolution just sort of happened to drop us off in that is susceptible to degenerative brain disease and limited IQ and limited lifespan and uh susceptible to all kinds of the dumb bacterial infections and lower back pain and bad vision and all these things uh you know I don't think we have any particular uh commitment or um allegiance to any of that we are going to be uh improving some of the some of the bad hardware and some of the bad firmware that that Evolution has left us with and at every at every level of organization you can think about augmenting these uh systems that were
designed by basically a a random walk with selection uh with rationally designed materials so I think that in the future all of you uh young people uh and and I think I'll you even I will get to see a bunch of this I think U will be living with a huge number of alien uh bodies and Minds we we already have some some people that are some degree of cyborg we will have hbrs and Chimas and synthetic life forms and uh you know because of because of that kind of plasticity of life that I showed you that interoperability is huge so uh any pretty pretty much any combination of evolved material engineered material and
software is some kind of living agent and all of these things are going to have diverse bodies and diverse minds and we are we really better step up and go well beyond uh very ancient and crumbling um uh rules of thumb about how we how we deal with each other you know in terms of uh what are you made of and uh and how did you get here you know those are the kinds of things that that we ask when we try to understand is something quote unquote machine that we can do whatever we want with or is it a living organism to whom we owe you know certain uh uh certain kinds of moral stances uh th those categories are going to go out the window because uh there are going to be all sorts of forms that challenge
those those those those superficial categories and what I think we're looking for is a kind of ethical synth biosis with a bunch of life forms that are nowhere on the tree of life with us so I'm going to stop here um and just say that if anybody's interested in in diving more more into this stuff here are some uh some kind of academic papers uh there's much more sort of General uh general purpose writings on this kind of thing at my blog um I want to thank uh the people uh who did all the work so these are all the the posts and the grad students who did the uh the the biology that I showed you today uh we have lots of um amazing collaborators none of this is possible without our technical support Personnel uh our funders um
again I have to do a disclosure these are the the companies that um that support our work and most of all the model systems you know the animals and and the the the microbes and so on because they they teach us everything here so um yeah thanks very much thank you okay I think um we have time for some questions so uh we will start here uh thank you this was very interesting um if I understood correctly you state that um this morphological plasticity and regenerative plasticity
is not really encoded in our genome but more in the bioelectrical properties and activity of the cells or the organism um however the Biol electrical properties of an organism or of a cell depend on the channels voltage dependent or independent channels that are expressed by a given cell which are encoded in our genome so in a way um the biotrial properties and therefore the all the morphological plasan regenerative capacity is encoded in our
genome well uh let's let's think about it so so certainly you need the hardware for any of it to work so without without the hardware without the channels none of this is going to work but encoded is a funny word um imagine I don't know if you've ever seen this thing it's called a gon board you can get it on Amazon for about 20 bucks it's a toy uh what it is it's a it's a just imagine a board and you bang a bunch of nails into it right uh and then you take a bucket of marbles and you and you dump it into the top of the board so the marbles go bang bang bang bang bang you know and they all land on the bottom what's what's the shape of the resulting marbles what you always get is this is this lovely bell curve it has a very particular shape to it and so you can ask yourself where
where is the shape of that bell curve encoded and uh so you can certainly it's not going to appear if you don't have the wood and the nails and the marbles but you can you can uh you can study the material of the wood and the nails and everything else all day long what you're not going to find is a direct encoding of that velker so the real question in all of this is to go to go beyond the terminology I mean I'm much less interested in terminology and more interested in what kind of uh what kind of conceptual framework lets us do better uh experiments in order to get new capabilities so uh if if if you want to make changes if you want to do to induce repair to fix birth defects to normalize cancer which are all things
we've we've done that I didn't get a chance to talk about the question is are you better off thinking about the material the hardware or are you better off understanding the software that happens there and targeting that and that's what that's exactly um what I what I was trying to argue that all of modern molecular medicine has done some some amazing things uh with respect to Hardware but most of what we are not able to do currently is precisely because we've stayed at that level which computer science and information technology Left Behind uh in the 40s so um yes the hardware is important but we don't all program with a soldering art and that's exactly what I'm saying uh as far as as far as these the reason the reason we were able to do some of some
of the things that we've done which had never been done before is precisely because we were able to adopt uh conceptual Frameworks from from neuroscience and from other fields that really take very seriously the the guidance of the final outcome not by the hardware itself but by the uh by the software components that are not actually directly encoded by the hardware but of course require it to function in the physical world thank you uh thank you for a very interesting talk uh my question was in relation to I guess you said it's not genetic it's more about the stimuli that you use to
change how the cells function and turn into what they're supposed to be I'm wondering like with those frogs where you were able to reproduce most of a leg if you make generation one of the frogs which were able to using the stimuli create this new leg would generation two of The Offspring if you cut the leg grow a new leg because you've reprogrammed those cells and at this point it is the genetic I know we're trying to understand the difference between genetics and the stimuli but would generation two have the capability and the cell memory to
regrow that leg Yeah great question uh we we haven't done the experiment um I don't really predict that it would because uh I mean I I could sort of I could sort of make up a a mechanism by which that would happen but I I I I doubt it would be actually uh that that this would be um uh transmitted to the Next Generation through the through the egg and and sperm and so on but but there is an interesting example of what you're talking about which is in these plenaria so we so we make these two-headed animals again perfectly normal genetics see that's that's another reason why the genome is insufficient for all this because if you if you just sequence the Genome of the two-headed and the one-headed form they
they're they're identical you would have no idea that looking at a two-headed worm it's simply not in the genetics for that for that reason uh those two-headed worms when they reproduce so the way these worms reproduce is they tear themselves in half right so they just tear themselves half and they regenerate now you got two worms so that's that's their mode of reproduction and under that mode of reproduction uh The Offspring do in fact inherit the two-headed so two-headed worms vision and they create more two-headed worms permanently so you've made a permanent line of animals that have a different uh anatomical structure and you can imagine you know we could throw it in the Charles River we wouldn't but you could imagine throwing it in the Charles River here in Boston and 100 years from now some scientists come along and they they
scoop up some samples and they go oh cool a two-headed form and a one-headed form must be a speciation event let's sequence The genome and see where that see where the speciation event happened and there's no difference between them that is not where it is and so so that kind of a thing does propagate because the animals are not squeezing through a single kind of a bottleneck of a single egg cell so there's a there's a chunk of the planarian which now remembers that it's two-headed and that chunk regrows into a new animal can can that pass through a single egg cell I I don't know we have no evidence that it can I could sort of imagine how it would happen but we haven't shown anything like that
yet hi thank you for your talk um my question is how you propose that this bio or this electrical information is integrated in these uh organisms um for context I work on the pack six regulatory genome so seeing these eyes kind of generate just solely from electrical stimulus kind of makes me think it's not the genes themselves but the DNA outside these genes but I would love to hear your thoughts on that yeah yeah great uh great great question so so a couple things so so first um just kind of a little inside baseball about pack six so in frog and and and pardon me if you know all this but but but in frog
pic will only induce eyes in the anterior iderm right just just in the front of the head and if you actually look at the developmental biology textbook what they tell you is that well the anterior Nector are the only cells competent to become eyes because they probed it with the master iene Pac six if you if you use pack six as your stimulus it's true only the anterior erected or can form eyes but uh but but if you but if you probe the cells with a with a with a much more meaningful stimulus to them which is these electrical States actually you find out that pretty much I mean we haven't found a region in the body that can't do it yet so uh you know these these competencies what we think of as competencies are really relative to how much we've understood the material we're
working with and the limitations of the material are you are often limitations of our understanding not the actual competency of the material so now so now how does it work so uh what we do know for for all of these cases is the molecular steps on a single cell level so we know that when we change the voltage we know the transduction Machinery we know how that voltage is converted to Second messenger Pathways how those turn various genes on and off some of them have uh have to do with um other kinds of Chromatin modifications we have all those steps all all of that stuff while it's important to know is really extremely unsatisfying because the phenomenon itself is not a single cell phenomenon so what I'm truly
interested in is not uh tracking down how one cell's voltage turns on specific genes uh that's just that's just part of the I mean it's an important part but it's just part of the story because what you really want to understand is okay but why the why is the whole thing scaled correctly uh what is the you know what's the difference between the hand and the foot uh what's the what why why the shape of a particular of a particular structure and so what we're doing now is we're using uh computational models of of network computations so not single cells but networks of cells that try to understand how the collective makes decisions about it size and shape and things like that so um so so there are for sure molecular
stories to be told about how the voltage turns genes on and off but what you really want is an understanding of why a particular voltage kicks off eyes versus legs versus and that whole conversation like what happens when when we when we uh induce these eye spots there's a whole conversation that happens between those cells and their neighbors because those cells are saying to their neighbors help us make an eye and so we we also need to understand it's not enough to know why those cell turn on various genes we need to know what are they saying to their neighbors and and how many and what you know how do they know how many of them there are but those cells are actually saying back no no you should not be an eye you need to be normal skin and that's a cancer suppression mechanism the cells that have weird voltages get told by their
neighbors through the Gap junctures they get communicated to try and try to normalize so there's a whole battle that's going on of of identities and it's not an identity on a cell level it's not stem cells trying to decide what cell type they should be it's it's large regions saying we are going to be an ey versus we are going to be a leg or or skin or whatever so that's it's um it's a very multiscale problem the same way that Neuroscience is multiscale where yeah there are people who study synaptic proteins but there are also people who study you know psychiatric diseases and um psychoanalysis and so on in every step in between all the network science in in between those two levels this is going to be that kind of science I think
uh thank you for your talk I have two questions one is uh what is the most uh frustrating thing for you for this field to move forward if it's not a secret and the other thing um maybe I missed it but did you mention how this electrical pathways are programmed in the beginning like initially and because you changed them so there was something that gave them at Birth yeah uh yeah good question so we can so in the Frog embryo for example we can watch them form from the moment of fertilization so what happens is that uh the process of fertilization breaks
Symmetry and uh We've characterized this from from the very earliest stages how the how the various ion channels that are that are present uh set up different kinds of electrical states that start to perform different computations and end up breaking symmetry amplifying that Symmetry and then making the decisions who's going to be left who's going to be right anterior posterior and so on so it's a combination of where so so where do these patterns come from well there it's it's a combination of uh emergence u in the same way that touring patterns right so people who study chemical signals have these like the this this formalism of touring patterns which Break um Symmetry and and create order out of um out of well- mixed chemical
media so some of it is emergent some of it is of course constrained by the hardware so you need to have the appropriate somebody was was saying there you know you need to have the right the hardware that's sufficiently powerful to do it which means voltage gated ion channels and voltage gated Gap Junctions and things like that um and uh yeah and part of it comes from wherever it is that mathematics comes from I mean this is really a philosophical question but but think think about it if if evolution once once Evolution discovers a voltage gated ION channel what you have there is a voltage gated ion conductance which is basically a transistor if you have a couple of transistors you can make a logic gate once you make a logic gate you end up
with a truth table that tells you how information is processed by that logic gate you didn't have to evolve that truth table the truth table is given to you for free including things like the fact that the nand gate is universal and various other cool computational properties all of that you get for free and uh you don't have to evolve it you get it from wherever it is that the laws of uh you know computation laws of mathematics the same way that if evolution discovers two angles of the correct triangle it doesn't need to look for the third it's can save all that time you know what the third is going to be so so there are all of these uh interesting free lunches in a sense that Evolution gets to exploit and uh I don't know where they come from you know PL Plato
and Pythagoras thought that they come from this platonic space of of of of universal facts that exist separately from the physical world um that's as good an answer as any at this point okay we have we have many questions so let's just um keep it keep the answers a little uh well so we can get everyone here H hi my name is angelene I'm I'm currently studying neuroscience at Columbia and I I want to know um I'd like to know what you think about Evolution as a mechanism of design like for example evolving a bot uh like a biobot instead of like designing it or like Evol both designing and evolving it
and and like would you edit would you edit Hawk genes would you uh take advantage of epigenetics and ALS and also you you sort of preempted this with your last answer how uh what do you think um how do you think we can take advantage of the vast Computing potential embodied in biological components like membranes like as like as you just remarked like logic logic a and ion ion voltage voltage controlled ion channels are basically the same thing and like there is a potential to program
that yeah um okay so there was a lot there and I guess I wish I was asked to keep my answer short so I'll I'll do my best and just pick one one of the things you said so uh we are we are doing a lot of work in programming both our xenobots which are the Frog version and the anthr robots which are the human version uh we are not touching the hawk genes we are not touching uh any any of that stuff um we are learning to to give them stimuli and take advantage of the cell's natural problem solving capacities we uh we are training cells with rewards and punishments we are trying to understand how they interpret various signals that cause them to uh acquire different shapes and functions and we're trying to communicate that to the cells and let
them figure out all the downstream molecular steps that need to happen for uh to to make it come true I mean the thing the thing with Evolution I'll just say one quick thing about Evolution which is that I I think Evolution works completely differently with an AG gental medium like this that is able to solve problems than it does with the standard story of of of evolution like um over a passive medium where where the genotype determines the phenotype that that middle software layer that that morphogenetic plasticity that allows it to solve problems makes evolutionary Dynamics completely different because uh selection has a hard time seeing actual genomes then what it sees is the outome of that competency process and so you
end up selecting for competency not for actually better genomes and that's an intelligence ratchet that goes all the way from uh from developmental mechanisms all the way up I think to uh behavioral intelligence uh thank you for the talk I was wondering uh if you consider like moving the eye of the tadpole from where it normally is to the leg as a deviation from the norm is there number of deviations that can be handled before the like mechanisms just break down and what's that threshold look like if there is one uh we we've we've never reached a threshold uh I think that uh I I don't I
don't think there's a there's any kind of a threshold in that sense I mean you can certainly overwhelm um met metabolically you can overwhelm the system it you know it needs a certain amount of energy just to undergo you know morphogenesis and of course that that plasticity is not unlimited I mean there are many things you can do to screw it up so that it cannot fix itself so birth defects are a thing and that's because these are not infallible Pathways they they adapt to a huge number of interventions but of course it's not it's not unlimited so I think I think the the the limitation is is um it's not the number of things the things you change it's the kind of things and whether or not you've broken the system's ability to uh remember what the right shape is uh and then and then act
on it hi Michael fascinating topic thank you so much so uh what I would like to better understand is how do you think that such complex information as the performance of a Tas task can be encoded outside of the nervous system since in the in the nervous system we have synapses and uh the fundamentals of learning a memory it's synaptic plasticin uh potentiation and depression of copses so how do you think that such complex information can be encoded and modulated through simply ion channels
that don't have sinapsis between them to communicate information uh well okay a few things so first of all I'm not suggesting that behavioral information relies entirely on ION channels that's not what I've said but they do actually cells non- neural cells do have electrical synapses between them I Gap Junctions which do store State and things like that but um o overall the the story and I know this is this kind of the standard story of Neuroscience that it's this you know synaptic plasticity and ltp and so on that that story not not from my work but from lots of other people's work that story is significantly cracking at this point um and I would recommend the work of Sam gersman Randy gallis um uh David
glanzman uh to look at some Alternatives because I I I don't think that's I mean well many people no longer think that that's the entire story and overall if I had to guess I think that the vast majority of that machine that you're talking about is not actually for storing memories I think it's for interpreting them and I think that there are there are numerous substrates within cells neural and non-neural that basically act like a kind of like almost like a reservoir Computing scenario but but a lot of the uh actual degrees of freedom are in chemical systems they're not necessarily uh um synaptic and and and the the neural networks are actually there to try to interpret it on the fly
so that's a that's a you know it's it's it's a long conversation to have but look up look up some of those papers and you'll see this is not this not my idea this is this has been around for for some decades now oh just keep your questions and uh answers like we have like 10 more questions so hey thank you so much for the talk um I'm curious on your thoughts about whether this electrical information can be accessible in higher order cognition and humans that might be in conscious perception and other organisms that might look a little different yeah I mean uh if I correctly I mean that's the the project of neural
decoding so lots of uh neuroscientists work on this this idea of reading out electrical information out of uh mamalian brains or including human brains to try and understand what the person is thinking hi thanks for the talk I'm cra um I'm wondering when you say all collect all intelligence is collective intelligence is there sort of a principled argument for that like can we imagine intelligences that we haven't discovered that could not be Collective like why are all intelligences Collective well uh as far as we know uh certain certainly on Earth um every
every intelligence is made of Parts uh I I I cannot I mean maybe somebody has better imagination than me but I cannot imagine a truly uh uh sort of homogeneous monatic uh single single object that is not made of parts that can change and that function relative to each other and so on that could then learn and uh and and and do the kinds of things we expect of intelligence if it doesn't have internal parts that can change State how how is it learning anything right it's not I just can't imagine how you could possibly have a an intelligence that is one indivisible thing that does not have internal states that can change every intelligence that
we've ever seen every every piece of active matter uh and and and intelligent living thing that we've ever seen is composed of Parts composed of Parts composed of parts I just don't see how it would be otherwise okay sorry um hi uh yeah great talk uh so I was curious about um have you done RNA seek uh before and after for example in that frog example um I'm curious if there any transcriptomic changes that you were able to see and if so um what are your thoughts on oncogenesis or enogen activation yeah uh we we
absolutely we've done tons of RNA seek uh there are massive uh transcriptional uh remodeling events that happen after the kinds of things that that we do also naturally so xenobots have a very different transcriptome from frog embryos anthr robotss have an extremely different uh transcriptome from normal uh uh human from from the tissue that they came from even though there are no genetic Chang changes no weird nanomaterials no drugs no trans genes no C synthetic circuits uh so yeah M massive massive changes and as far as ancoines the story that I didn't tell you is that uh there's a there's a there's a whole uh way to look at cancer as a kind of dissociative identity disorder of this collective intelligence and what that means is that you can
actually address it not by trying to kill the cells but by trying to reconnect them back into the uh into the electrical networks and so what we do is we inject alag like Kass M mutations and so on into these embryos normally they make t they make tumors but if we then manage the electrical conductivity correctly even though the Ana protein is blazingly expressed you don't get tumors you get perfectly healthy tissue with cells that are participating in the network activity and doing what they're supposed to do so there is a there is a cancer um therapeutic story here as well hello Michael great talk thank you very much uh so I'm a neurosurgeon I have an interest uh observation that you might find uh
cool to so we we have had patients that we operate on uh say lose some function speech and then rehabilitate after six months they're back they uh regain their speech back and when we operate on the same patient again the same spot where we lost speech last time is completely rejectable and no function change occurs so this uh this is very rare I didn't I saw this kind of phenomena happen three four times but I was uh and I'm uh not familiar with your field uh but is there a paper you can direct us something that
uh that describes what you are describing here the moro memory and you know the regular memory uh how do they work in human brains uh well okay there there are lots of pap uh how they work in human brains is very unclear because obviously experiments are really hard uh for ethical reasons you can't do this in in in in in regular humans there is some clinical data drop me an email michael.
ls.edu send me an email and I will shoot you some reprints of of what we have hi professor um what do you see is the biggest problem we need to solve before using this to program organisms the biggest problem is uh is conceptual uh the biggest problem is developing an uh an understanding of uh how we are going to recognize and communicate with a uh a collective intelligence in the sense that even I mean we've we've we've done experiments with Gene even Gene regulatory networks uh without without
the the rest of the cell without um changing promoters without any of that just by their dynamical properties have six different kinds of memory that they can do including pavlovian conditioning Ju Just Just grns on their own and so so that the ability to recognize that that kind of property and to learn to engineer with an agential material not not the way we've engineered with passive materials which we've done for Millennia but um a material with an agenda a material with a multiscale set of goals and and competencies and problem solving skills it's a completely different way of of engineering it's a communication and a collaboration with your material it's not the kind of micro managing that we've been doing for you know since the beginning of the scientific Enterprise so that that
that's th those th those issues are are the biggest barrier uh thanks um I noticed you guys mostly use like endothelial or epithelial tissues for like the xenobots
divide it die and so on yeah interesting uh no I mean we've done we've done everything we've done mism iderm we've done human meenal stem cells the reason the reason the Bots are epithelial is because uh that's that's those are the tissues that are ciliated and they have the little molti motile cyia and that's uh that that behavior that allows them to swim and to be visibly to have visible Behavior now I also think that uh there are many interesting behaviors that happen in physiological and transcriptional spaces but for our first kind of outing of this stuff it was important to have behaviors that people can see and really recognize as behaviors so for that you need them to be motile which means cilia which means epithelium cool
thanks hi thanks for the talk I really enjoyed it um I had a sort of question about uh the role of uh you mentioned membranes were used to sort of predict the next Downstream series of events and uh inell events that contribute to the gross development what do you think of epigenetics and how you would sort of encode that in the computational model and sort of what those next steps are like methylation alcal all those different types of things because you you accounted for membranes but not I guess those types of changes and I guess more realistically how do you account to encode those as next steps that a computational model might predict or even Downstream yeah we we have them in our model so so we know there are
acetalation and methylation events that are Downstream of the things we do um it's it's there by by itself it doesn't really it doesn't really add much um all all of the uh the the kind of high level decisions about what's going to happen are made at least as far as we've been able to see now they're made uh at the at that electr physiological level all the gene expression changes direct or indirect through through chromatin modification or Downstream um yeah they're there you can model them but but but they're not they're they're not a great um target for for modification you know if you if you want uh I mean there's certain things that you can do that way but but typically if you want to make these large scale changes you're
much better off doing it as high on the on that uh that control hierarchy as you can by the time you get down to the chromatin modification you are having to micromanage a lot of things to get what you want hi uh thank you for your talk I was really interested in the conditions of this kind of initial bioelectrical field um you showed several examples of for example cells creating bio like sending bioelectrical signals amongst each other in order to stimulate growth in a certain way I'm wondering when it came
to maybe like the first organisms or organisms in a vacuum are we kind of sending out certain frequencies or electrical stimuli in order to simulate that or what were those types of kind of initial field conditions yeah uh good question I mean we we we are uh living cells put out all kinds of things across the electromagnetic spectrum uh Ultra weak Photon emission all kinds of AC kinds of Mag you know weak magnetic um uh kinds of things uh I I don't study any of that so I have no idea really what the implications that would be everything
that I've shown you was purely electrical there's no magnetic component really here uh no no waves these this is purely electrical and it propagates through water so uh the stuff that I showed you doesn't really work through air um but having said that it is it is true that that living things do do emit electromagnetic radiation but I don't think we know what what it does thanks all right last question yeah so thank you so much for this talk um just a quick question about like because I guess you can kind of call what like like a Programming type of question um how would you like
describe the type of like bugs that you encounter so to speak in this situation so let's say you want to create like a worm with two heads and like the outcome is just different than what you expect like how do you I guess first of all I'm guessing you've seen that in second how do you like deal with quote unquote debugging that yeah uh yeah great uh the biggest the biggest issue here is that you you have to think completely differently than you do with regular programming because in regular programming uh at least most of the time you're dealing with an obedient passive medium so so when you have a command whatever that command may be you are pretty much guaranteed that the hardware is going to carry it out it may be the right command it may be the wrong command but but but when you say you
know add these two numbers if if you know if your Hardware is not actually going to do it then you really don't have a good computer right the whole the whole the whole point of of Hardware is to is to isolate those layers so that the at at the higher level you don't need to worry about where the electrons are going you can assume that the chip is doing what it needs to do and it's going to get carried out biology isn't like that at all so what's happening here is that every level has its own agenda so when you are providing certain signals what you end up with are targets that uh either aren't paying attention or they are paying attention and they refuse or they actually fight you on it because they're going to do something different or uh they have some other thing that they want to do and uh this happens at every level it's not just be
I mean behavioral scientists know know know about this because because um it's it's really hard to do experiments because of individuality cells do this too so you're dealing with a material that is not a passive material that has uh well separated levels of abstraction where each each level can depend on the bottom level to be perfectly obedient they are all pursuing their own agendas they are cooperating competing communicating with each other interpreting each other the the the computational Paradigm that Josh bongard and I have come up with for this is called poly Computing and it's simply the idea that you have a a huge number of coexisting uh uh interpenetrating agents which are all interpreting and hacking each other in different ways so there's not a there's not a single uh
interpretation of what an event is actually Computing in our Computing architectures we all agree when when there's an endgate we all agree this is this set of physical events that's an and gate it's Computing in in biology you have uh lots of little observers in inside the cells and the tissues that are all uh interpreting these events as completely different computations and we as a third person sort of third party Observer often have absolutely no clue what they're doing and and that's that's really hard it's a very different way of programming amazing well what an amazing talk and thank you so much for let's give profess 11 another round of applause yeah thank you so much great
questions I really enjoyed the discussion yeah awesome okay now we will also talk a little bit about decentralized science and I'll follow up you're welcome to stay or um whatever is good so um let me share this tab here thanks everybody I've I've got to run been a long day I thanks a lot great discussion thank you okay so um let me switch over here so oh yeah so first off um decentralizing science is important so
the first part of decentralizing science is attracting more people so if you enjoyed this event or you wanted to share with another person make sure to uh and make sure to post it it really helps us you could take out your phone I hate to I hate to be annoying about it but everyone should take out their phone and like take a picture and send it out to other people even if it seems weird now but um like just help it helps um we have information about I'm going to give you information about our oh first the um uh we want to thank the people who uh gave us this space today which is alchemy um and they are uh the most reliable way to build web 3 apps um specifically nille uh college friend was
very kind to generate uh uh give us the space donate this space um so this is the D NYC Community um we have lots and lots of speakers we've had this is the 14th one we've done we've had uh people on mushrooms and blinded studies and bees and Ai and nfts uh all sorts of things and we have another one oh we have a we have a community if you want to join ah see now people take out their phone um we have a telegram group so you can like stay in touch um after the event with each other just giving another hint here you have your phone out now okay
um we have a website so dnyc we have all our uh previous events there we have the videos we record everything we posted online um we have swag you can get other things like that you go back to oh yeah cool okay um this is our next event on August 1st it's going to be amazing um there's going to be it's on this guy who's like doing this like uh is like super siiz me you remember that movie with like McDonald's and um he's going to be doing like super super
siiz me but with like wearables um it's going to be really cool I spoke with him uh a few times and he's an interesting fellow and he's developing like a new type of wearable for your toilet and and he's trying to like destroy his gut right now and then heal it and then crack the process and we're going to be the first ones to uh hear about his poo um oh this is one thing we're trying to do more of like having like a volunteer group um right now it's sort of a like a like a Skeleton Crew That's doing this um oh thank you Brian for helping tonight thank you round of applause
Bri and love as well on the video and um and Brian on the code also and um so uh if you're interested in volunteering um for the next event here we'll get dinner we'll assign roles and you can help out be part more part of the crew and pick speakers what was it after April uh I forgot to update this slide okay so now I'm going to talk about um like why is why is what is what is decentralized I I wanted to do this talk before but he was he had a a tight constraint Professor 11 so we'll do this
talk after and I want to just say like why why is it important as as a society and as like Humanity that we like um decentralize science so like imagine like the inter like right now universities are the like science is like hugely beneficial to humankind right so like that's one of the probably one of the best metrics of progress and right now like a lot of it's in like research and development labs and it's done in um like universities but the quality of the research and and these things is all it's very tightly kept as a secret and also that um sometimes the quality of of like academic research is
really bad and it's like not reproducible and imagine a world in which like the internet was like a giant lab where people could like contribute data to it and get rewarded for it and I think that like this is not too far off I think like universities are you know not as like not as important as they were 30 years ago and where is that science and Innovation going to happen it's going to happen on the internet and this is like extremely valuable and the people that participate in it should get rewarded for it so with this sort of premise is like if you want if you had this as your goal what would be the easiest way to do it is you would use this blockchain instead of just for like
Financial incentives for like uh swapping tokens and like you swap some Bitcoin for some ethereum on Unis swap which is cool but like the underlying value attached to each of the tokens is like sort of arbitrary whereas if you like instead use the blockchain to assign uh each token were assigned to a research project or to intellectual property or to a new drug or to uh bio electricity and then you allowed people to like swap those types of tokens for the IP that's attached to those or contribute to a research project this could be really cool and uh make new SES of projects happen and maybe fund um things and I want to emphasize that like this isn't far off I don't think that we're that far off from this sort of
thing existing in the world I think it could be within the next like two to five years I think it's very possible and then the the other big thing that's changing around like why why this is possible now is um is like AI is like going to be a scientist very shortly so the idea that you're a PhD student and then you have you have six years of knowledge and four years of undergraduate in this very specific domain is is like and now anyone can be a research scientist um with just like access to Cha gbt and you can get up to speed very quickly so in this like new decentralized science thing I think it's possible to have like a thousand times the number of scientists that exist today because um there's a lot of people
who aren't part of a university who want to become like a a scientist people will be incentivized so that you don't have to do it through like um like you get like a crappy salary at a university like no one wants that like people want to be like incentivized to do really great work and so I think that this is is very possible to have like wealthy scientists and a lot more of them and like similar to how like maybe like 30 years ago or 40 years ago like there was only a couple computer programmers but then like computers became cheaper GitHub became available tools became easier to use and then there's like everyone is a programmer today and I think the same thing is sort of is we're on the cusp with that for um science so
um uh it's like it's like what D is going to do for science like it's going to decentralize science but how many people know what defi is just in general decentralized okay lot defi is like decentralizing fin Finance so that's like the idea that instead of like opening a bank account at Wells Fargo there's probably a lot of people who can't open a bank account who would like to be banked and so having like an ethereum wall a Bitcoin wallet address or address and allowing them to swap different tokens opened this up to a lot more people and also removed a lot of the middleman so here's a little table I made um we call this traditional science on the right and decentralized science
on the left and I I I start off with this is just sort of the process of um a typical science application so the first thing is funding so I hate funding because like normally if you're not getting funded as a scientist it means like I've never seen like a really talented scientist complain about funding so it means like something else is wrong but it's it's the first thing here so we'll start with it so the funding is like a lot of funding happens because governments are fund a lot of research So like um the National Science Foundation or the National Institute of Health and the problem with that is like they just fund very specific things and they don't go Broad and they only fund things that
they know they don't fund moonshot ideas but in dii um you have access to a lot more people so you can crowdfund ideas and you can go a you can do a lot more crazy stuff Publications uh are very broken in traditional science so uh Publications in in traditional science that go through a peer review but the peer reviewers don't actually read the papers they just sort of look at it and move on um in in dii anyone can be a peer reviewer and you can like bet on individual contributions um then uh data sharing so in traditional science data is very locked and in dii the data sets are like open and you can pay and reproduce experiments very easily um Community uh
like in in a traditional science setting like you only have you only sort of do research within the lab setting but in Dai um you have a global access you can access a lot more people which is cool um IP can be shared governance is instead of just like a uh the the lab manager doing all the research and directing things uh everything can go up to a token vote so if there's a question about should we do experiment a or experiment B um instead of just relying on one person to do it you can you can issue you can have like a vote on a snapshot and decide on what do and use the collective intelligence to figure out what the next step should be and then the reproducibility I think is one of the most important ones like I think
in a lot of research today um like most of the papers are are not reproducible because they're either too complex they don't reveal enough about how their meth methodology or uh it's uh the P value hack and there's all sorts of issues but in dii all the because everything is disintermediated between physical entities everything is sort of logged on chain so you could easily just like replay back everything and see which sort of science which science is valid and which science is invalid okay um so the way it works is like if you want to create a dite project you first create you have an idea and you say I
want to create an ideaa around sleep and um everyone who contributes to that project is issued a token so maybe you contribute through um giving sleep data Maybe you contribute through uh doing an Al uh developing some sort of algorithm maybe you contribute through um recruiting people and for each of these different things you're get you get tokens um and these you we have the data pools so people can sort of contribute to a data pool so if for example for sleep you can use like the aura ring and contribute to a data pool and that data pool will then be accessible to anyone who's interested in uh
sleep other types of data pools that I think are really interesting are like blueprint is very popular these days so like longevity like how do you how do you determine if these types of things these interventions work is you're going to need like very very um like broad data sets so things around like food um things around ordering and things around like gen genomic data are all going to be really really interesting to determine like uh these These are these are Prime data sets to figure out like what's working and what's not working um you can you can do a lot more with like data quality so right now in a in a research project um people just
sort of like put in things and like maybe the phdc will like look for outliers and remove those and then sort of move on but when you have like a decentralized science system people can like um stake on data so when you submit data to a research project you can submit like uh $5 along with it and why that's important is because if you then if you contributed bad data like you can get slash so you'll you won't get your $5 back so you sort of like spam the system and then you you'll your data will be removed and so it's incentivizing you to produce like high quality data that can be verified um and that's like these these are the types of
things that you can do um with with like d but not with like traditional science um people can just like you could have like a uh an exchange so of like coinbase you can you could have like oh I want to invest in or I want to invest but I want to participate in um like Bitcoin or crypt or like ethereum and similarly it could be like oh I want to participate in an HRV study or a sleep study or uh a CO2 study so it sort of opens it up to a lot more people um and then this is one of the more interesting things you can like instead of like how many like how many people know what a prediction Market is okay so imagine a prediction Market
in it's just like a it's like a a betting Market or like you predict what's going to happen in the future and if you're right you win tokens and if you're wrong you lose tokens and imagine like a prediction market for like scientific experiments so you're incentivized to um think about like which types of experiments are going to work and which type of experiments are not going to work and this in this like this is like this is very different from peer review so peer review is like I have no skin in the game I don't care if this paper's been accepted or rejected now let's like flip that around if I'm correct this paper is correct I'm going to like earn tokens now I'm like going to spend a little bit more time reviewing it because it's like you want to you want to do really good diligence on it so the the upshot of this is like
you're trying to align incentives between like high quality scientific research and um like the the the outcome for the individual person okay so basically like we're trying to build a platform that will like enable people to participate in decentralized Project or to spin up one um we've started it already it's called um water bearer. science and we're looking we're we're hiring so if people here are interested in decentralizing science and and um like particip specific roles we need are like we need like a VD and a community manager person since it's a little we're we're we're we we have like like a lot of people
inbound and uh we can't really respond so we're trying to grow uh we're VC backed by uh like some of the best investors in crypto so if you're interested uh we're very hum hiring here's our application um it's very short uh we're in person um we work uh like hours but it's all in person which I think is good and uh I think this is like a great Community to pull from so if you enjoyed this event and you want to participate more uh definitely apply and then oh that's it do you have any yeah you have any questions oh uh
ditec yeah yeah uh so uh I have a question so normally uh the Govern uh so some of the biggest sources of funding for science in government comes from uh DOD defense energy and medical and a lot of times they put that science right into applications which generates return for them uh what do you see the biggest as the biggest drivers for daa in terms of funding yeah I think there's a lot of people that are just passionate about things like I would find that Michael 11 researches because I think it's cool like I would much rather give money than like some other like random like charity
um so I think that's one I think people that have a specific need for it some like a rare disease like people are much more interested in participating in that sort of thing and if you give them like a pathway to back credible people and participate in that type of research I think that's another one um and and then people who are just interested in science as well like I think there's a lot of people that want to continue education maybe have uh knowledge and they enjoy doing it in their every time and also I think the costs are decreasing so like previously it used to be a lot harder to do a science project but there's a lot of like clinical research organizations and a lot of Automation and a lot of AI that's happening that's I think bringing down some of the costs associated with like traditional
research I mean I guess following up on not oh yeah good um I guess it's kind of like a follow up but there's usually a lot of Ip coming out of research too and spin-offs and startups and so on um um I assume that that could be also a framework where incentives could be aligned if you get part of that is that part of the entire equation or yeah so that's the that's like how it works is you have an idea around like let's just take an example of like mental health like so you create a mental health Dow around a specific topic and then everyone who participates like that sort of wraps that's the IP any IP that's created as part of that group is
tokenized sort of and everyone who participates and does work earns tokens based on their participation so if you contribute data if you contribute analysis if you recruit patients if you publish it you become you you get these tokens commiserate with your how much you contributed yeah and so that's Sol that's one of the things that's nice about D is like it solves the IP issue so in like a in like a traditional setting you'd work with the University's Tech transfer office and they take a third and a third and a third and it becomes impossible and a lot of people a lot of research dies there for partially that reason but here it's much easier like all the data is tokenized and there's a lot of liquidity around it so you can exit or enter back in if you
choose you can also like um uh uh what's the word I'm looking for uh vest some of the IP so it keeps people invested in the project like one of the project one of the problems now with like University Research is people graduate and then they leave and like but if they vested over maybe a longer vesting period they might be more incentivized to stick around thanks Michael you mentioned that if someone spams the system with incorrect data that that could be removed how would that happen if it's on blockchain uh yeah I mean it would just be marked each each um there's a couple different ways of doing it one is to allow any data and allow like some agent to just it depends on the research
project the the simplest thing is allow all data and then use some sort of AI or human to judge which is good and bad quality data um the second one is to do it like a community voting so you have like a a jury and they vote on each piece of data to see if it should be accepted or rejected or maybe you could use something like a liquid democracy approach where you can assign your voting power to another person and they can vote on your behalf of if this data is good or not and you just trust this person and then the cryptoeconomic way of doing it is to um have people stake money on their data so when before you can contribute the data to the data set you have to you contribute it along with a $5 bill if your data is accepted by by
the community you get your $5 back you get your data accepted into the community and your tokens in return and whatever benefits are associated with those tokens but if your data is considered bad by some standard then the $5 is removed you is kept by the community and um the data is thrown away and you might the next question you'd ask is like um what prevents like why would you contribute to what if there's a bad community and uh they just kept all the money as associated with the data that's come in and the answer to that is like um all transactions that have been submitted to the Dow for to accept the data are on chain so you
could review the previous connect the previous submissions and say like they've submitted 100 people have submitted great quality data and it's all been rejected this Dow is um is terrible I'm not going to participate in it anybody else cool well um thank you all for coming it's amazing to see all you here and uh I'd like to see you on October on August 1st we might do one in between time we haven't scheduled it yet but the August 1 one is the next one and if you're interested in decentralized science or you know someone that is share it with a friend and recommend
them all right thank you guys [Applause] I