Talk & transcript
The Billion Oyster Project
Zeke King Phillips & Cody Herrmann
Transcript
Download textAutomatically generated transcript. May contain errors. Select a timestamp to watch that moment on YouTube.
[Music] so what are what are your plans sure I know L okay so like you're yeah that makes sense [Music] uh you know I see I see I do research work so I'm basically research scientist I actually [Music] love okay um hello uh internet people we're going to go live soon uh don't worry we'll just give you a little pan around here
how much was this was like like 400 bucks yeah this is for the internet hi internet hi internet hi interet I'm GNA get you on you guys want to say hi to the internet say hi to the internet say [Music] hello what would you say uh we're decentralizing science one drink at a time [Music]
[Music] want to say anything about D this is for the internet yeah yeah you want to say anything no
okay this is on the internet how we doing I'm so excited about the oysters what why are you excited about the oysters because clean the Hudson River cuz what got clean the Hudson River you know you can yes okay clean the Hudson River okay cool more oysters the cleaner the water what more oysters the cleaner the water yeah okay cool what excites you about science the possibilities cool infinite awesome okay cool all right I'm get do you want to say anything to the internet do you guys want to say anything to the internet no no I'm good
thank you my first here first time okay do you guys want to say anything to the internet yeah one do you want to say anything to the internet hi internet she'll be speaking later do you want to say anything to the internet oh um we're happy to be here these are our speakers for tonight the little internet okay little by
internet you guys want to say anything to the internet do you guys want to say anything to the internet no
or selling or honestly I all right we're going to start all right we're going to start
um we're gonna start don't
want okay we're going to start everyone find the spot don't sit here all right everyone find the
spot guys um
awesome okay in the back oh also someone could ask the um bartender to turn the music off for someone guys in the back CU otherwise we're we don't have amplification so uh everyone's going to have to actually be quiet um door could you ask the bartender about door could you raise your hand if you're here door um bartender got he's got oh you got oh thanks thank you okay um okay uh thank you guys all for coming out tonight it's an amazing turnout um
we had a we have and we ALS thank you also to the people on the internet that are also watching um we've started a live stream and it's great to have people um I'm just going to keep it really short this time um decentralized science is about making science fun and interesting and making it more open so if you're interested in that um you can follow us on Twitter you can tag us you can follow us on Instagram um and we have an amazing uh array of IM of videos online um I also started a company called Stadium science and that's around making betting fun and interesting if you're interested in that you can check it out that's the people that sponsor it we work together with them um I think
without further Ado um we are going we would also like to thank the space um everyone should get a drink um and U mention the the code that we told you earlier um you get 15% off make sure to get a lot of drinks we're very grateful for the hotel um to and and the event space for being able to host us and um without further Ado we'd like to help welcome our oyster people on stage um they're part of the dillian oyster project which is trying to make the Hudson River uh more interest more clean and also to sequester carbon so without further Ado I'd like to welcome [Applause]
them you can get start no worries thanks for having us um uh so I'm Z King Phillips I'm the senior community stewardship coordinator for the billi oyer project uh I run one of our community science programs is ecological monitoring yeah and again thanks so much for having us super excited to be here U my name is Cody Herman I am the senior community science coordinator at billion oyster project um and much like Zeke um you know we do a lot of community science and a lot of different ways for um non-scientists to engage with science um and we're going to talk to you guys about some of that
tonight um so show of hands who's heard of billion oyster projects before awesome yay and show of hands who has volunteered with billion oyster project like a corporate volunteering okay yeah some of you that's great um so billion oyster product is a nonprofit based in New York City whose main focus is restoring New York's Harbor um through ecological restoration so we're really looking at putting oyster reefs in the water and we want to do that in a really public and participatory way um so we do a lot of public programs and a lot of educational work as well in relation to the ecological restoration work that we do so really our big goal is we want to
put one billion oysters in New York City's Harbor with 1 million people by the year 2035 um and we really need your help to do it but the good news is we're also on track to do it so you know come join it'll be fun um we say this a lot but we do education through restoration and restoration through education um we really have a tight partnership with the New York City Harbor school which is a public high school located on Governor's Island where our main offices are um and even from like you know a teenage level a high school level we're really giving people the tools to get involved with this type of aquaculture industry fabrication and all these different types of things um we really love oysters because you know they filter
water so they clean the water in the harbor they provide habitat for other species in the water um and they also provide some protection from storm surge but what's really so important yeah um but what's so important about the work we do at billion oyster project is really its ability to give people an experience with the harbor and with the water which historically New Yorkers have been you know pretty set back from and pretty separated from um so through our work people get to engage with the harbor get their hands dirty get their hands wet really see all the life that's in the harbor and through that we hope to kind of change the culture in New York City um to create more stewards and people that care about keeping our Harbor clean so for our
process um one big thing we do is we collect shells so we're going to set all these little baby oysters on shells right to make reefs we get those shells from restaurants in the city um so we have a shell collection program that goes around to different restaurants that all of you might eat at we have about 70 restaurant Partners um that you can find on our website we take the shell that they give out to customers um and we basically put it on like a giant pile on Governor's Island if you've done our corporate volunteer days you might have seen this um but it's like a pile as big as this room I want to say right really big um the shells go and cure there um so there's no more bacteria in them before they get put into our oyster
installations um and some of how we do that is through fabrication um so right now we're producing a lot of reef balls with our volunteer teams um and you know some of the shell is worked into that concrete that makes those wreaths um I don't know if you volunteer you can come see it it's pretty cool so besid shell collection and Fabrication we also do a lot of oyster production so once we kind of make these Reef Balls and other types of loose shell that oysters grow on um we have to raise oysters so I have one cooworker who's always talking about like oh gosh I got to go home I have millions of lives depending on me um because we have big shipping containers where we kind of Harbor little oyster
larve and hope that they attach to our big wreath balls and different pieces of shell and things like that um once we have our oyster Reef um or our our Reef ball set with oysters then we can go and use our boats to deploy them throughout New York City's Harbor um so this is actually a picture in Brooklyn Bridge Park um if you've been to I think it's like the Pier 4 Beach um this greef ball with bunch of baby oysters on it is in the water there with oysters growing today right now so exciting um for the last 10 years that billion oyster project has been around we've been able to put about 19 Acres of oyster Reef into New York City's Harbor um which if you want to think about what 19 Acres
looks like it's like double the size of Bryant Park Bryant Park is about 8 Acres so you know picture that twice so our big numbers here is so far we have put more than 150 million oysters back in New York City's Harbor over the last 10 years um across 19 Acres um we have engaged over two thou or 20,000 students at different schools and through different education programs um and engaged more than 15,000 volunteers some of them are you in this room which is so exciting um and we've diverted over 2.5 million pounds of shell from landfill back into these reaps that we're helping to make so cool back to our agenda um we
did introductions we did our billion oyster project info and here's Zeke with why oysters okay so I'm G to cover why oysters um besides the fact that people like to eat oysters which I'm sure most of you in this room probably do um although I should mention you cannot eat any of the oysters in New York Harbor uh that is simply not safe um we do it as Cody said for three reason the first um this is a really good figure if anyone's interested we probably have this on our website um next one the first one is water filtration so a single adult oyster can filter about 50 gallons of water in a day um which is frankly
impressive for an animal that's really only about that big um but if you think about a billion oysters by putting a billion oysters in the harbor we could filter the entirety of New York Harbor in three days um which is frankly very impressive and uh super important because as Cody will talk about later water quality is one of the other areas that we're really interested in um and there probably a lot of people in this room anyone who been around the city for a while has been told not to touch the water um and there are certain reasons for that but oysters with a billion of them in the water could really help to remove a lot of the pollutants that we're putting in the water um specifically um one thing we mention here is excess nitrogen as I'm sure
everyone who's interested in climate has heard of like elal blooms and dead zones these sort of marine issues that are the result of like runoff of um fertilizer and also marine or also sewage runoff um these issues could sort of be cleared up by putting a ton of oysters in the water as a nature based solution the next one habitat and biodiversity um there are a ton of associated organisms that uh sort of end up living wherever an oyster Reef pops up not just because they like oysters um like we do but also for a number of reasons very specifically as part of water filtration oysters make their own
mud every sort of everything that the oyster doesn't itself want to ingest doesn't want to digest they will wrap up in mucus and drop to the bottom of the harbor and what's called a pseudois and so basically that pseudois is really good um food unfortunately for other organisms like worms like bacteria that will deal with those sort of unwanted um particles and debris so this is an example of what an oyster Reef might look like and a ton of the associated organisms you can keep going they're just going to pop up um you have allergy you have the oyster here obviously but on the oyster you have an oyster toad fish um you have a
bunch of red allergy you have Barnacles and tunicates and a lot of these other Associated organisms that live in oyster reefs not just because of that food but also because these reefs provide frankly a great place to uh like a coral reef to rear young um provide safe habitat places to hide from predators these are all sort of ecosystem services that oysters provide um to other organisms in their habitat you yes there's more there are so many Associated organisms and this is just a slide to show you a ton of stuff um will come to the harbor basically if we put a ton of oysters in the harbor to build that habitat the third thing that oysters do
is Shoreline protection can I get a show of hands who seen Moana please cool awesome so I think basically usually I put the clip for Moana I skipped it today because this is an adult crowd um but basically if anyone remembers the scene from Moana where she's trying to leave the island she crosses um her Coral wreath and basically immediately falls off her boat and almost dies um part of the reason that that happens like the island of MWI that Moana was is protected by its coral reef a bunch of oyster reefs around New York Harbor would help to protect our coastlines um and our archipelago for anyone who hasn't thought about it New York is in fact an archipelago um would help to protect our islands and our Shoreline from a lot of the dangerous wave energy
that would um threaten to like basically take away a lot of the soft Shoreline if you think about satin island Jamaica Bay um Long Island Sound a lot of that is really soft Shoreline it's a lot of beaches and that's really easily washed away by heavy storm storms by heavy wave energy um and so by putting a ton of oyster reefs in the water instead of waiting a thousand years for those oyster reefs um this is an example of the living break Waters off of the coast of Staten Island that anyone's flown into L Guardia from a southern approach recently you might have seen a lot of gray rectangles in um the lower Harbor those are not reefs but they are foundations of reefs it's a bunch of rock it's a bunch of these sort of reef structures that will be seated with
oysters to sort of jump start that wreath process and protect that Island Shoreline from that wave energy um cool um moving on now I'm going to explain one of our community science programs that's the oyster research station program um oyster research stations they're about this big yay big is they're 18 in by 8 in by 8 in these are what we call Institute Laboratories basically just little structures that allow us to study oysters in their natural habitat we these little metal cages that as Cody said are fabricated inhouse by our volunteers with up to 200ish wild um reared oysters not wild
oysters we rear them ourselves um and basically these structures help us to understand how oysters will fare once we put them in the water um what we use the structures for is basically two things education and data collection so we have community members um yes a bunch of different groups of community members we have Community scientists who are just community members like yourselves if anyone super interested and wants to get trained um about how to measure oysters how to understand their mortality how to servey biodiversity um we have community- based organizations that we work with like Brooklyn Bridge Park Conservancy like
Hudson River Community sailing um we have teachers and students teachers will use these structures in their classrooms for Hands-On science learning directly on the waterfront with their students and we also have what we call our ambassadors these are really in-depth volunteers um who take it upon themselves like our community scientists to go out and measure these structures on their own the point of doing all of this data collection um either with us or independently is very specifically to understand the harbor to connect people with the harbor but also to contribute to the restoration of a self-sustaining oyster population in New York Harbor we use the data collected through the um oy research station program to inform our
permitting process and when we're applying to put more oysters in certain places we'll use this data to say awesome it looks like our oysters will grow well here um and we hope that The Regulators agree with us um so these are just a bunch of pictures some of you are far away but won't be able to see basically just a bunch of examples of different events and different groups of people using NE research stations um okay I'm going to cover right now a little bit of the data that we collected this past season mostly figures and I'm going to talk through them um these are the sites where we do more intensive data collection for the oyster research station program specifically with our volunteers if anyone I know I'm sure most of you have
stuff to do uh 9 to5 Monday to Friday but if anyone happens to find themselves free on a Monday between 10: and 1 we do regular volunteer events at these sites where people can come um with basically now experience and get Hands-On uh experience measuring our oysters and surveying biodiversity next slid this is some of the work that we did this season basically water quality monitoring to understand what water quality looks like in terms of like the environmental parameters that might control oyster growth around the harbor the three here are temperature cinity and dissolved oxygen which are three parameters that are sort of known to affect oyster growth um the green bars represent the ideal growing conditions
and basically as you can see the dissolved oxygen in EUR caror always looks great sometimes it's remarkably High which is weird but great for the oysters um we have our salinity generally to be expected this is an estuary the tide blows in and out twice a day and then we have our temperature as you can see the shoulder months are kind of cold but like that's also to be expected it's supposed to get cold in the winter this is just to show that like New York Harbor really is the ideal place to grow oysters on a small or large scale so this is what this season looked like at those the six or seven sites where we did the STA collection um the initial height for each of the groups of oysters at those locations
that were put in for this specific purpose um is about 20 millimeters so that's um about an an inch um this season and we saw remarkable growth frankly across all of our sites the highest growth being at the baylander if anyone's been to Bayland or steel Beach at West Harlem Pier you might see some of our cages um hanging in off the G locked there but basically uh across the harbor really good first year growth the next one uh our new oysters per cage not only this season did we see a remarkable growth but we saw remarkable recruitment it looks like not only our our oysters doing well it looks like the oyster
population we talk about oysters perhaps like they haven't been here the entire time for the past 400 years but they have there's an oyster population that's doing really really well up the Hudson um and it looks like perhaps they're spawning and that's leading to recruitment at some of our sites particularly as you can see the Hudson is doing really well in terms of recruitment there are baby oysters they are um the adult oysters are reproducing and those baby oysters are making their way perhaps down the Hudson um and growing along the shoreline of Manhattan not so much in the East River but I will say um as you can see in the figure below there's sort of a reciprocal relationship between Recruitment and mortality just because if you have a lot of oysters dying it's hard to understand
understand exactly how many oysters um new oysters have appeared but basically this is just to say that despite the fact that mortality looks high this is to be expected mortality should be frankly upwards of 80% in the first year for most marine invertebrates um so I would say 36 35% mortality is really good um next slide I'm just GNA pause if there's room there's room in the front over there because it's really hard to hear so everyone who's here in the front move to the left go to the and then yeah of room if anyone particularly the people on the ground might
[Music] this okay this figure is my favorite it's the only thing frankly that I really care about it's the biodiversity that we find at our oyster cages um I'm just like a 5-year-old as soon as I see a fish I jump on it um but basically these are our top five species and the relative abundance across the season some of our sites there's really no diversity you're seeing mostly grass shrimp and mud crabs uh frankly that's to be expected because the salinity of baylander is so low it's a little bit high up in Manhattan but as you can see we have relatively good diversity um I didn't put the species richness up here we found about 36
unique species across the harbor this season so pretty good um not only are the oysters growing well but also the biodiversity in the harbor um has Blossom frankly cool summary slide a bunch of pictures of cool stuff we found this season I'm GNA go through that first because like I said that's the only thing I care about um a black seab bass a spot thin butterfly fish which we didn't know you could find in the harbor um a spider crab which is my favorite thing um and a seahorse we found five of them this season in case anyone is wondering there are seahorses in New York harder but um just to summarize we saw impressive first year growth across all of our sites we saw um mortality
rates that were within range and we saw amazing recruitment in the Hudson River this season together these findings suggest that like restoring an oyster a healthy self-sustaining oyster population New York Harbor is well within our reach all we frankly have to do is put the oysters in the water um the data from these oyster research stations as I said is used to inform our restoration effort so if anyone is super super interested you can come up to talk to me after this presentation and I will give you a QR code to sign up for this season um but also as I said this information helps us better understand where we should Target uh which areas of the harbor we should Target for like larger restoration efforts in the future we have a ton of big projects coming up
so if anyone's super super interested you can follow along um on our Instagram Co hi I'm back um so another side of what we do um again we talk a lot about oysters but we really like getting people down to the water and getting people to touch the water one of the biggest barriers from having New Yorkers come down and play in the water all the time um is actually called combined sewage overflow do you guys anybody know what that is okay cool a couple people we're about to get into it um but we're going to talk about the water quality
testing program um and spoiler alert it's all about human poop in the harbor so when we talk about water quality we can be talking about a lot of different things you know it could be temperature dissolved oxygen um other parameters that Zeke just mentioned um things like oil or petroleum chemical waste algae turbidity litter um pH all these things um but today we're really just going to talk about bacteria so during in the community water quality testing program which is a community science program that all of you guys could get involved in if you'd like to um we only test for entra caucus so entra caucus is a feal bacteria um it's found in the intestines of all
warm-blooded animals so that's me that's you that's like a goose somewhere um and other mammals cats dogs stuff like that um and um entus bacteria isn't necessarily the thing that's going to get you sick um but when you find it in whatever you're testing um it normally means there's poop in there so when we find asra cacus in New York's Harbor um you kind of start to wonder like oh no what what is that is that a bad thing um and yeah it is pretty bad um obviously when we talk about like being able to swim in New York's Harbor um you really need to think about like tides and currents and are there boats you know is
it like a physically safe place to be um but the thing that would like make you like poop your pants or vomit in a couple hours would be coming in contact with the sewage bacteria right so that's again one of our big barriers from enjoying swimming in the harbor or even like kaying if you think like oh my God I might fall out of my kayak um and drink like a mouthful of poop water you know like that's where you're going to get sick really quickly not in like a long-term way from some of the other like more industrial and Legacy blut um and yeah if y'all are into bacteria we test for ENT entus nauy coli just because it lives better in salt water so and it looks like that if you ever wonder it's a little like okay so how
does hakus get in the harbor um it's through this thing called combined sewage overflow so what we have up here is a little diagram um here is like what happens normally on the left side of the screen um so basically when you flush your toilet at home it goes into a pipe underground and that pipe takes your waste um to a wastewater treatment plant and those wastewater treatment plants they can handle all of the waste in New York City during dry weather so if it's not raining and you're using the sink at home you're running your dishwasher you're taking a shower you're flushing your toilet all that water goes into a pike to a wastewater treatment plant it's cleaned and put back in the harbor
um on a rainy day though which is what you see on the right side of the screen here all that rain water um goes into the same pipe as all your waste water from your home um so it's a combined system right a combined pip um New York City just isn't doesn't have the sewage capacity to take on all that rain water along with the waste from your guys' homes so what happens there is that there's simply just not enough room in the pipes um so as little of one tenth of an inch of rain in an hour can trigger a combined sewage overflow and that means that after it rains just a tenth of an inch in an hour which is a really like tiny amount right that's kind of just like wet on the floor type
of bag um you know that's going to trigger a combined sewage overflow event and the city will expel raw sewage and unfiltered storm water straight into New York City's rivers and streams um it sounds kind of crazy but it's actually pretty common in older cities I think there are 700 municipalities throughout the US um that has this issue on AC of question where in Europe city is that happening is that um it happens Staten Island actually has the least of it believe it or not because Staten Island was built a little bit later and developed a little bit later so at that point people already knew there's an issue with this type of combined sewage system um all of New
York City or 60 to 70% of New York City has a combined sewage system it's throughout all Burrows and really the way that it works is there are about 418 combined sewage overflow points so that's where like that sewage pipe literally meets the shoreline Edge um and you could like go look in the tunnel which eventually like goes back to people's homes you know um it's I love it don't laugh it's really cool um I think it's fun um it's really hard to get those maps of where those tunnels are because it's like a homeland security issue also don't joke about the tunnels you know you could do a lot in those tunnels um but anyway all jokes aside about 27 billion gallons of
raw sewage and storm water are expelled into New York City's Harbor every year 27 billion that's a lot we go to the next slide and just a quick shout out to geese because geese also poop a lot on like the beaches where you might want to launch your kayak or like weit into the water and again they're like warm blooded they have entus too so sometimes it's just like you know we don't know if it's human poop or goose poop but it's the poop that'll make you vomit if it gets in your mouth anyway next why so again some things we just went over how does interus get into the Harbor New York City has a Wastewater and a storm water problem so New York city sewer system pollutes the harbor um about 60 to 70% of New York City has a combined sewage system underneath it um like I
mentioned and I can show you guys some maps as to figure out how where you fit in all of this and where your toilet flushes to later um yeah we could of already through a lot of this so the other 30 to 40% of New York City has what they call an ms4 um and that's where like the sewage pipes are separated underground so no matter if it's dry weather or wet weather your toilet flush is going to go to the wastewater treatment plant but in those areas which is about half of Staten Island also just just for fun so you know um those areas any litter that you throw on the TR in on the street or anytime like a dog poops and somebody doesn't pick it up and then it rains all of that that gets caught up in the storm
water and flows into a storm drain is always going to expel directly to the harbor so there's really like no perfect solution when it comes to this storm water issue um and as we see more rain from climate change and as we see more people living in the city more water lines more to Li flushes um it's actually a really complex problem to try to think about um New York City's Harbor is unarguably the cleanest it's ever been but when we look at an issue like sewage pollution it starts to get a little more complicated oh and then 5% of the city has direct drainage so those are like the homes in Howard Beach where the toilet just goes straight into the harbor but we don't talk about that I don't want to disrupt what they got going on that's the secret
stuff okay so you know how can we mitigate this issue what can we do it really comes down to upgrades to wastewater treatment facilities right you're not going to H be able to stop that water from going into the harbor unless your pipes are big enough um and there are a bunch of other things we could do like retention of storm water and sewage um so that's essentially just like big storage tanks called gray infrastructure have y'all heard in ganas about this big sewage storage tank infrastructure project so this is kind of a picture and you can see the scale of it so this is like a huge work track that's like a little CAT Excavator um this giant pit that's ultimately going to hold I think 12 million gallons of sewage and storm
water um during rain events which is going to stop a lot of the sewage overflow from a place like from going into the guanas canal um and then you also have the Detention of storm water is another thing that can really help this project problem um so have you guys seen rain Gardens on the sides of the roads so there's like a little curb cut I see a lot of P nods we love that so these rain Gardens are actually really important to stopping your poop from going into the harbor during rainstorms each one of these Gardens can hold about 5,000 gallons of water underneath it um and that water slowly seeps back into the Earth um instead of going into our Wastewater system and overloading it so every one of these is taking 5,000 gallons out of the Wastewater system um
which is greatening the capacity to treat actual sewage um which again is what it's just gross to have the poop water in the harbor right so one rain Garden at a time right um or really big infrastructure projects so that is to say in the meantime while we wait for these big infrastructure projects or some of these smaller peace meal infrastructure projects like rain GID um we can test the water right and we can create that data to understand which places are polluted which places need that infrastructure investment which places need more rain Gardens um and really kind of understand where Advocates can help make the harbor cleaner so that's a picture of our water
quality job and stuff is the vibe if you want to do it little gloved hand little jar could be your um so the community water quality testing why do we do this and what are we doing so in 2012 the New York City water Trails Association started this water sampling program um it was really a bunch of boers and kayakers um that wanted to focus on bacteria testing near public access points and the shoreline Edge so places that you know people might fall in places where you know people you know might be exposed to that bacteria um and over our 13 Seasons we have collected over 12,000 samples at over 140 different locations and again this is really all just Community scientists
um I was a community scientist volunteering for this program for like seven years before I got my real job um which is always exciting um but you know a lot of people have put a lot of time into this program and created a really beautiful data set um that anybody can use and it's totally public um it really fills in gaps left behind by the testing programs that the states the F the state the FED it's and the city have set up um they really don't make that data publicly available so if you're a kayaker and it just rained on Thursday and you're kind of like damn I don't know if it's too gross to go kayak this week the city and the state and the FEDS don't really provide that data for you so that's why this group of Voters was really like wait we have to take things
into our own hands and start collecting this data um and yeah historically We compare our bacteria data to the same standards that the New York City Health Department uses for beaches so if a Beach is open um it's because it has passed the bacteria standards of the New York City Health Department that day um and that's kind of what we judge our data on even though a lot of the places you know aren't really safe to swim because it's like a fery stop or something um but we know that there are kayakers and people there using the water so it's still super important to know so what we do is every Thursday morning again this is for like the last 13 years now every Thursday morning a
bunch of people go out and collect these ENT pocka samples and these little jars this is a nice picture of brn Bridge Park also um and on Thursday afternoon they drop those samples off to the labs they process in an incubator for 24 hours um Friday afternoon we get our results and we send out a big newsletter which I hope you guys subscribe to on Friday afternoons um or Friday evenings and that means you get your results about bacteria right before you're ready to go do your weekend Recreation right right so again this whole timing of the project and everything we do is really centered around getting people into the water safely slide um some of our Water Quality Partners um really all your
faves are here um there's really a lot of organizations that have worked with this program over the history of its life um and we're always looking for new organizations to get involved too so if you work in or around a park um and you don't know if there is sampling or whatever we want to hang out we want to play we want everybody on the water to kind of be taking in data about combin to a d though so we use what we call the idex ENT ento alert system um so it's really easy um it's like the only way the test for entus bacteria that's EPA approved and only takes a day other things take like about a week the membrane
filtration and stuff which kind of sucks because you want to know if you can go swimming or boating like now right you don't want to wait a week for results and then be like oh I guess the water quality was good last Friday I can totally go out this Saturday you know it just doesn't make as much sense so this ID enter alert system um has really helped us be able to get more rapid results um in a cheap way you know ultimately it's not that expensive um and what's really cool about ID's little patented uh enter alert system is that when the bacteria incubates overnight and eats the reagent that we mix with the sample it then glows under black light so it's like a little like party moment I'm always like I want to have the entra caucus party with the black
lights um but basically we put all of um the samples in these trays and then we count the glowing Wells to determine the number of bacteria in that sample we share the data so that swimmers and kayakers and boers can all you know understand kind of what they're getting into um we color code the data um green means go right that means the New York City Health Department would be like you can totally swim here um yellow means definitely use caution um the way that I interpret this yellow kind of intermediate level is like if you've recently undergone chemotherapy or you have an autoimmune disease or you're a little older with a weaker immune system
that water might not be good for you if you're young and healthy you could probably get away with getting a little splash and like feel no pain um and then the red you know that's totally like user discretion um if you like fell into that water you very well might get a rash or you might get sick or something like that because the um concentrations of poop the health department says you shouldn't put your face in it that's kind of they're like can you submerge your body in it can you put like your face holes in it Health Department said do not do that um but I think you know the yellow and the green is kind of like a know your body know your limits type of breing um and red is definitely
beware um we can also take our data and compare it to state and federal um result uh standards as well which we'll look at in a second um but for the most part you really look at the health department standards because that's kind of like the shortterm you know are you going to be okay if you fall in type of stuff um we have a site map so you can go see all our sites and all our data by site um this is what the data sheets look like um they'll show you some other information like sample time and like the rainfall that week in Central Park and with all that information can kind of determine the trends per site um or just like if it's cool for you to go kayaking that day and how careful you need to be about coming in contact with
the water so last year about half of our samples came back not safe for swimming which could be alarming but also it's a community science project right so a lot of places that people have chosen to sample are actually like really disgusting places that need a lot of love and attention um so happens that people are really interested in like polluted waterways like New Town Creek and the ganas Canal you know people love these waterways which is great because they need a lot of love to kind of come back to be healthy and functioning ecosystems um places like the East River places like the Hudson River we don't necessarily have as many samples from um
because you know people are a little less interested in these water bodies that you know get love and are like more well represented however if we compare 2024 to 23 we see a really big jump in the amount of bad samples we saw in 2024 um which is kind of strange because we actually had less rainfall um so you know there's a lot that can go into these um results but you know fun to analyze if any of you all are into Data analysis and models and things like that you know how is this happening why is this happening um we can go to the next slide so we also really break down the geometric means of what we call the MPN um when we read our
little blackl trays of water um it gives us a number that's kind of like a um oh goodness I'm blanking um cfu is that it yeah so cfu that's like if it grow grows on a petri dish is cfu and we just kind of like have our medium suspended in this tray so they measure it in MPN but it's the same as like cfu if you think about it that way um yeah these geometric means are like the easiest way to really look and understand the quality of your sample site um we did not see a lot of good geometric means this past year um in 2023 it was really split like evenly we
have about 90 sites per year um you know areas in O with open water with more current like the East River and the Hudson River we see much better water quality whereas when you go to these smaller tributaries that are narrow that don't have as much current like New Town Creek Westchester Creek the brounce river flushing Creek Cony Island Creek you see much worse water quality results there so for example last year the best site that we saw in New York City was Hudson River Pier 40 um which is where the River Project is maybe y'all have been there as well really good water quality um most samples that we took there were like safe for swimming um whereas the worst site that we saw in New York City this past year was in
Newtown Creek and Dutch kills which is the Little Creek that curves around the back end of Long Island City um really funky in there right it's like this far away title tributary the clean water from the East River doesn't really get that far up to flush that sewage overflow out it's kind of a common story and kind of predictable um and this is comparing our water quality to the state standards so you can see where we're not meeting City standards we're also not meeting State Standards um this basically means that the city and the fact that it you know puts out this 27 billion gallons of raw seage every year is non-compliant um to state standards and to Federal standards um they basically
just pay a fine every year and uh that's how we deal with this um there's a lot of room um in this space for more policy advocacy um and really a lot of things we can ask um from Regulators to help us you know make things match up a little bit more um and have realistic standards for maybe what is expected um or you know standards that actually might feel attainable or a path to get there lots of room so if you want to talk more about it you should um and of course does New York City need cleaner water what are you guys think nice um so you know we really need cleaner water because of the EPA Clean
Water Act it says all water bodies in America should be swimmable and fishable um you know Zeke said you can't eat the oysters around here right so it's not really fishable um you can't really swim in the water because you might eat human poop and vomit you know so we don't we're not there right um so of course we need cleaner water um but you know without big investments in that green and gray infrastructure it's going to be really really hard to tackle this sewage infrastructure problem um and it's really only going to get worse due to climate change right we're getting more and more rainfall um but also because of increased population in New York City too it's also another thing that's making this a little more challenging to mitigate um you know another thing to think about is as extreme heat becomes
more and more of an issue in New York City you're going to inevitably see people turning to the harbor as a place to cool down um if that water is full of harmful bacteria um those people not only are they going to be really really hot to the point where you know their lives may be in danger they'll also be coming in contact with this harmful bacteria um and might not know about it you know they might not even know that they're exposing themselves to that when they go to the water to cool down um so this seage issue is really you know an environmental justice issue a climate justice issue and something that we as New York ERS really need to think about um when we think about you know equity in the face of climate change um some research and information
for you so the New York City Department of Environmental Protection has a map um for the ms4 areas if you want to see if your poop does not go into the harbor look up the dms4 map um if you are interested in finding the combined sewage overflow that your poop goes into when it rains which I highly recommend you do and you go visit it and you start to understand where a little part of you lives out in the harbor potentially um you can go to open sewer Atlas it's hosted on a tumbler so you know this is like an old school Vibe um so find the open sewer Atlas tumbler there will be a map that you can go to there you can type in your address and see you know
where your poop flushes to when it rains um and then of course you can look at the city the Department of Environmental Protections map of csos which doesn't show you all of them um but it shows you the big ones and most of them are in those tiny little channels and tributaries that we talked about earlier that have bad water quality because of lack of current so you'll see that they're in Flushing Bay flushing Creek the Bronx River bowy Bay Westchester Creek the Harlem River New Town Creek um Pate Basin all of these are really tiny channels um with not a lot of Shoreline um that are just getting like totally blasted by human poop during brainstorms um really something to think
about and look at when thinking again about like equity and infrastructure and development um if you want to stay in touch with us and I think these QR codes may or may not work because the thing's a little out of focus but you know let me know um you could subscribe to our newsletter so you can get all the latest sewage news and also our water quality results on once the season starts up um and you can also become a water sampler if you want to become a water sampler on the right over there there's a form an intake form um and I will email you back and will'll try to find you a place example this year and I can give you this presentation like three more times throughout the year because it's my favorite thing um cool other ways to get involved with billion oyster project
outside of sewage solution of course you can come volunteer um again a lot of those fabrication projects that we talked about um whether it's building the oyster research cages that Zeke talked to you about or helping to fabricate Reef Balls um we have events to do all those things you can visit one of our shell collection restaurants so all of our restaurants are listed um on our website as well bop. NC you know real easy um you can find one of our restaurants again 70 restaurants where you can eat at knowing that those shells will go into a future restoration project and stay out of landfills 80 now we have 80 restaurants we've been coming back since the pandemic it's been a slow crawl but I think we're so bad um you
can also donate to billyon O your project of course we love that um fun the work we do um you can check out other events we have a great events page um get involved with with not just a program Zeke and I have told you about but tons of other monitor opportunities that other staff do um of course you can join the community Science Program like me and Zeke just spoke to you about um and probably the most fun option is coming to the billion oyster party you got any hot take on this um the billion oyster party is Fun the ticket price is $200 but it is unlimited oysters all night so you can probably open bar open oysters um it's in September every year um it's a good party it's kind of
like a Brooklyn Warehouse in the Navy yard but like oysters just packed door to door like all you can do is eat oysters and hang out so I hope to see you guys at the party and yeah I think we did it time for questions
sh the process yeah you mean um the question for everyone who cannot hear was have we thought about deploying with seaweed you mean putting new oers on seaweed [Music] yeah um I we haven't done that not but there is a new nonprofit seaweed city um that's also working on Governor's Island um that's been seeding lines out in New Town Creek and around Governor's Island as well um you know if their habitat is making habitat and our habitat is making
habitat it's going to be great um we have worked with steing City a little bit just helping them like with their lines um on Governor's Island but we are Sals haven't incorporated into our design um is there
Clos offshore offshore offshore would be very interesting um if you happen to be able to take an offshore sample every Thursday morning um it's rough Saturday not so much again because we're try this specific program we do a lot of Thursdays huh Wednesday nights Wednesday nights talk about it we can figure it out um but again we're kind of on like a strict Thursday schedule because we have this Friday used letter Vibes you I didn't make the rules it's just how it is but we do need to kind of come up with ways to expand the program based on
capity yeah I think you know you a lot question oh sorry so asking um besides ocus bacteria there are other indicators you can look for for um FAL pollution um kind of on a more shortterm scale um dissolved oxygen typically relates a lot to the amount of sewage um just because those nutrients are going to cause algae to grow and then the algae is going to kind of deplete your dissolved oxygen levels in a lot of cases um in super pollutant tributaries you'll see bad do that might care with that well I don't know if you have anything help to um there's a good body of work about disease to oysters in addition to like filtering the water because they filter
the water they're also a really big repository things like you can find drugs and oysters that like pass out of us and into them you can find diseases and oysters so there are um it doesn't measure the quantity in real time but you can see like what is passing out of us and into our ecosystem through the just um not as helpful as Inus but not yeah you can also test for things like soap you know because if you see soap in the water again that's probably waste from we work this way or should we start on the other side I don't know where you're right in front of me so if the
real cause of this is due to the rainfall and uh the Wastewater getting out why focus on oysters as they seem like some sort of secondary thing when the even in your presentation you mentioned like the gray water infrastructure or the forgot what it's called the green you know so like why what are you know don't want to solve those problems before we start focusing on oysters oysters love eating food um so we're really lucky oh sorry I keep forgetting to repeat the question um the question was should we be focusing more on the sewage pollution issue than the oyster issue um and focusing more on
infrastructure improvements than natural rest or nature-based Solutions um and you know I think there's definitely a balance to it to be quite Frank um billion oyster project started with this mission of Education through restoration and producing oyster reefs um not so much on the water quality Zone it kind of came in after um but again it's really related to our mission of you know providing access to the harbor yeah I think my big point is that it is significantly cheap for us to just put oysters in the water than for the city to spend multi a lot of billions of dollars we're talking like 10 20 billion to fix the
problem um I think perhaps I mean it's really it's us doing the oer restoration like we as a community as an organization don't have the funds to fix that issue I also would say like the gray water infrastructure in guanas has cost 10 20 $30 million which is the amount amount that it would cost us to put probably about 300 million oysters in the water so I think like it's really a cost issue um and also like Cody said what we're how we came into this yeah you guys talked a lot about like s pollution but um how big is say
the other pollutants that you guys talk about maybe like harmful industrial chemicals or oil such are they as big of a problem solution as sewage or yeah um so there to the so the question was about Legacy chemicals not seid pollution but like pcbs and peas and all of those other heavy metals the chemical pollutants that like were dumped into the harbor for literally hundreds of years um those are quite honestly still there um they are just at the bottom of the harbor buried in the mud so um the Army Core of Engineers I believe was looking at um specifically around fairy
dock the remobilization of lot of that sediment as remobilizing those pollutants um we focus specifically on a Terra Caucus as Cody said because like we inherited this health issue um in terms of the ability to oysters to deal with those pollutants probably not as good but I think I don't know they're all there there are like tens of feet upwards of 30 feet of mud that is just pollut Laden at the bottom of the harbor so much so that the solution very frankly is to put cement on top and just hope it doesn't move um I think it would require much more money and effort in terms of remediation than anything this city or
this country or this state is ever going to put into like fixing the problem um is my personal feeling about that you know we're lucky that people don't just illegally dump like they used to um the harbor is so much cleaner than it was and that's because you know we built more wastewater treatment plants but also the culture and regulation around like industrial dumping it just doesn't happen the way that it did before so now it's not like petroleum leaks that are stopping us from enjoying our Harbor it really is more this like infrastructure issue with the sewage can you talk about the distribution and allocation of the are
you allocating them to the yeah um so we have about a dozen reefs right now the question was about the allocation of oysters around the harbor are we focusing in heavy heavily polluted areas um we have about a dozen reefs that are scattered around um once again to be quite Frank I think the location of those reefs is based on where the oysters will do best which isn't necessarily aligned with the most heavily polluted areas um not to say that oysters wouldn't do well in heavily polluted areas my personal opinion is that they actually love living in sewer outflows because it's just more food for
them gross as that is um but in terms of where we've done our work it's mainly in areas that we know our oysters will grow well or there are other interests like Community interests or um Financial interests so we have reached like sound view by the fairy terminal um which is up near City Island in the Bronx near Bron neck um Jamaica Bay and it really is just about like where they grow um and where they'll grow best and also where um the state will let us put the oysters that's also a very big concern they really won't let us put them anywhere that's like too heavily polluted to close to large sewer outflows um because of concerns about
sort of the oysters and the environment and coing so yeah I think the state actually discourages us from putting them too close to these highly polluted water bodies because we know that people probably will eat these oysters um so it's kind of we call it an attractive nuisance um typically where you know these oysters are probably going to attract people doing things we don't want to do with them like them is the type of oyers that you guys change how much water filter or specific species so we only work with the Eastern
oyster um which is what's native to the harbor um you know before colonization um the oy oyster kind of used to the Eastern oyster in New York City used to be like as ubiquitous as like a hot dog cart so people used to just be like selling oysters on the corner for cheap um because the Eastern oyster used to do so well here yeah I will say there's only one species of oyster on the east coast and that is the Eastern oyster across the TR virica um so if you ever eat an oyster from somewhere else it's the same species it's just like the water quality and different characteristics make it look different um but yeah as Cody said we're focused on like restoration of that former ecosystem um there are other projects like Chesapeake Bay I know at the beginning was looking at craa um
gigantica which is um another species of oyster that we won't deal with uh but because we only have one native species I think that's like the preference not only for us but also I'm going to be so honest I don't think Regulators would like us putting a non-native species in the haror yeah my favorite is zek's important fourth thing that they do that we didn't talk about yet no it's actually okay so my secret the question was what's your favorite oyster fun fact um my favorite oyster fun fact is that some people think about oysters potentially as a SN
for carbon um just because they incorporate CO2 into the shells when they um like do when they create their shells they basically oyster shells are made of calcium carbonate which is three things calcium carbon dioxide oxygen um so it is potentially a sink for carbon I can't be quoted on that because we don't have a number um I guess that's mine is that um one of the theories about how Typhoid Mary got her typhoid was actually from eating bad oysters just because um as we pass sort of as I've said drugs diseases all of those things go into the harbor oysters eat those and they can live in oysters for a period of time that I can't personally quantify um
so we have researchers have reached out because are interested in looking like presence of voice of Co and pneumonia and oysters as ways of tracking like the presence of those diseases in the city um so yeah t and oysters pass to Mary and then hundreds of people after a good one um the question was do we have any genetic or genomic data from the oysters in terms of yeah um so I'm not super familiar my
first inclination would be to say that the hatch like the genetic span because we buy all of our ERS from hatcheries right so the genetic diversity between different hatcheries because you're looking at the same species I'm not entirely sure it's wide enough to provide any certain advantages um but I will say in terms of where our oysters come from there has been some in terms of the recruited oysters that I talked about there's been some interest um from some of our external partners and looking at whether the oysters that are recruited and some of the sort of blank shell bags we put out or some of the cages we put out um are coming from the wild oyster population that's further up on the Hudson or from our um our
aquaculture population that we put in the water um I have heard tell as in I've read um the paper by Matt a Cornell who said that the Upstream population is not providing any larae to like Downstream so like they'll spawn but they're not making their way down here I don't know if I believe that but that's what I can say about the Gen sorry yeah I just had a question so U I know you're not eating any of these oysters but do you have thoughts on microplastics nanoplastics that are in the oysters because I I stop EA Seafood because of all microplastics sea particularly the question was about
microplastics and oysters and are we worried about it and I'm so glad you asked cuz last year our intern did a project on microplastics and oysters yeah um I will say I don't mean to scare anyone um I read a couple of papers today about quite literally microplastics and not just oyers but also Seafood I think the most recent review that I read said about 60% of global fish populations probably have microplastics in them and 94% of oysters globally um have micras Classics and that's um a combination of like micro beads and micro threads so whenever you wash your clothes if you're wearing an acrylic a polyester synthetic frankly um you're
shedding microplastics those do end up in our oysters especially um with our sewage system as it is anything that ends up in the water does end up in Oyster so yeah oysters are repository for Plastics as well um but to be quite Frank all of us have Plastics inside of us anyway so yeah um but even when you know we had a high school intern last year and we just had them like cut open some oysters and just look under a microscope it was pretty lowy you know it was like super simple stuff and even he was able to like clearly identify like fibers and plastic feeds like all these different shapes that you know you don't really find in nature it was very obvious like oh that's a plastic or that you know so even just at a glance a
16-year-old can find a microplastic in your oyster things make pearls oh can we make our oysters make pearls I get this question a lot thank you for asking um the Eastern oyster does not actually make pearls I will say I've seen their attempted a pearl it's kind of gross it's kind of um shocky and instead of being incased in flesh like with the Western oyster I think the SEO oyster makes pearls but don't quote me on that um uh instead of making a pearl they'll like attach it to their shell as a nodule so even if it was pretty and made of the same like neck you probably couldn't get it off uh so
they do not unfortunately make pearls the way that like pearls normally work is like while they're filtering they'll get like a little piece of debris in them and then build up that Curly outside around that piece of debris with the Eastern oyster they kind of just like push it to the top of their shell and that's why they're kind of lumpy and freaky looking um which I just think is so New York at the end of the day what's uh what's score how many oysters out building um yeah 150 million yes 150 million this summer I'm going to say we'll probably do 50 to 70 million um I haven't looked at our
pipeline but we'll probably top 200 by the end of the year um and we have plans to scale up very big very fast so we'll get there we have 10 years so yeah basically I think over the next 10 years we're trying to put about 100 million more oysters in every season roughly um to get to our goal in 10 years's the yeah I think the the question was what a scaling up look like in Oyster production um I think you know obviously funding is a big issue it cost a lot of money not necessarily to like take care of the oysters but to do those
deployments you know it's a lot of boats it's a lot of moving people around it's a lot of Labor um and a lot of time fitting things and that can kind of get wonky um also baby oysters are kind of hard to keep alive um the larval stage we kind of had massive die offs this last year right um yeah yeah um so the die offs that we saw last season weren't just our oysters like we're not just killing them um our hatcheries actually had a bunch of crashes um I'm not entirely sure what happened um but frankly if oysters got more expensive last year it's probably because of that um the other thing I'll say is permitting uh Regulators really are only comfortable with a certain amount of
oysters at a time that's totally understandable so we're not just like overwhelming the ecosystem but it we do have to come to an agreement with how many we can put in the water with the regulators and I think that's also a factor um are the oyers more oyers the question was um what do what would be the negative impact of putting oyers in the water are they taking up space or food from other organisms um I think it's just that you know again
dealing with oysters in New York City's water is very difficult for Regulators because you want to protect people that might be eating them um so you know these big influxes I think are also like how do we survey and advantage and make sure that populations aren't eating oysters and the more that you're putting in you know the more you have to do a that yeah um so what I'll say there is not the oysters are really lucky in that um we have eaten so many oysters and like decimated the population in the harbor over the past 400 years so much that like when we put oysters in the water it's sort of um an innovation we call it habitat uplift there's not really competition for food there's not
really competition for space because we are creating new habitat basically um the only other really large scale ubiquitous by valves um in the harbor are muscles which aren't really occupying the same Niche um so yeah there's not a ton of competition between W and other organisms you did mention a lot about like mortality rates and one of the goals to eventually have them reproducing themselves and driving their own organ like organically producing or is it something that you feel like at the end of the road might not be enough a
little yeah um so the question was about mortality and about whether our goal is a self-sustaining or a reproducing population um we say self- sustaining population is our goal very specifically because we do want them to reproduce um but also we are the billion oyster project and that billion number is just the number we're going to dump into the water um we that doesn't count the wild oysters that are already there that we have evidence they reproducing we see new baby oysters every year we saw recruitment in the cages um so they're doing super super well um it takes about three to two to three years before an oyster is ready to reproduce so the oysters we put in last year won't be able to
reproduce until next year so if there are sort of large scale impacts um in terms of like the amount of larvae being pumped into the water by our oysters it takes a couple of years for that to happen um but as I said there is evidence that the oysters that are in the water whether they're ours or whether they're the native oysters are already reproducing so basically what we're trying to do is just to give the population a jump start um we're trying to put a billion more oysters in the water we don't have a quantification or like a number right now on how many are already there um across the whole Harbor but like that billion should help to jump the formation of a new large scale um ecosystem scale population and lately
we've been looking at places where wild oysters already exist um and understanding you know how we can help those reproducing populations kind of like move a little past where they already are and then you know the spat and larvae from that Reef maybe it finds its way over across the East River to like another installation we have and like those communities all throughout the harbor can start to support each other else did we do it awesome yay [Applause] than I hope I still have a
job yes thank you all for coming great audience [Applause] [Music] thank you for the amazing talk we are really big into we got you a NYC mg so it's air yes and thank you guys for the talk so let's give [Applause] round wow this is great yeah of course definitely thank you yeah you guys can all chill and enjoy get some more drinks at the bar um yeah that's all thank you
guys thanks so thank
[Music]
start my and
meet your name [Music] [Music]
[Music] oh
[Music] College Point but again size
thank you [Music]
about
[Music] [Music] is
[Music]
want
[Music]
you can get out [Music] really good
[Music] know
[Music]
yes [Music]
[Music]
it had a break
[Music]
IM un
[Music]
[Music]
iide
[Music] you
[Music]
appar really all
put the
[Music] [Music]
show
[Music]
that's always how it is [Music] I
[Music]
want
[Music] the things that people
I'm like [Music] [Music]
[Music]
[Music]
[Music] [Music] that
[Music] Che I'm like really bad at
they don't
[Music] [Music] on
what
no I
volunte of now I'd like to Mo but [Music] so I'd like to I'd like to do that in climate
[Music]
here
like [Music] [Music]
[Music]
gu there
[Music]
[Music]
[Music] it is every
shot [Music]
[Music] [Music] [Music] why I
[Music] [Music]
that's where you're picking [Music] 20 [Music] points I want to know what they can do for like one start ask questions [Music]
radar can they can they just scar check how many we got [Music]
see he's mad at me now he's mad was W questions on my phone and yeah the one time he like I was my questions I was like I was like oh this would be sick I was try form
[Music] [Music]
I'm praying that I get paid next months it's
yes how I get what uh that was one email I just emailed him oh it was great it was it's also online if you want to watch it yeah
[Applause]
we're literally in the water
um Lally
[Music] nor every day yeah wanted to go
[Music]
EMP
[Music]
are cultural and [Music]
were
[Music]
us
[Music]
l [Music] [Music]
[Music] crazy I have so many kayak in myar and like
Fus getting these communities to which iians Step righted
[Music]
Angela Angeline right
[Music] what
you [Music] but
[Music]
[Music] City so yeah [Music]
I got I got
a [Music]
[Music] o
[Music]
I I got figure out what
[Music]
our I
[Music]
[Music]
after
that's [Music]
again
it's know [Music] [Music]
[Music]
[Music]
of
said
that's
[Music]
way get
no
[Music]
[Music] [Music]
[Music] [Music] congrats Russian
[Music] [Music]
Drive no way [Music]
[Music]
literally just going to say yes [Music]
they came to show
for everything for everything is there something it doesn't cure no it CES
[Music]
be
[Music] yeah I [Music]
[Music]
oh oh I have a
looks like
okay yeah okay so there's no
battery very gener
so terms actual
yeah yeah no
11 so
the [Music] [Music] you of money but yeah my major concern like terms of gentics is ago that
there's T seed oyers B seed I grew up work o [Music] it's really bad we buy lar and them like basically see directly the tank onto the structures that we use now we're looking at some direct seing methods in some locations like terminal about SE and then um plant out planting at that size so they're generally
not big um so we're doing it the summer we will start setting and so for the RO calls we start setting probably in about June we give them a few weeks and then we them out before they're even like like very small program they probably don't go out until before I would say for about a year e we'll call them because first year morality is like 80%
right from lar to the super high and so we will wait for the oysters that go into the engagement structures after a year we'll call them so only putting in shells with oysters on them all the empty shells will take out might D might re and so those will by the time they go out yeah but if you are interested yeah um we are always interested in looking something comes up and get wants to do sequence saying yeah yeah um and potentially I'm talking
so I see thing you know if you guys could give us the sample yeah even like Uptown downtown people love that you know what I mean like like the Uptown downtown rats yeah love that's I know you told me that you're very your face just upat I love the rats I'm a rat proponent Soo I I get it sorry I think that our choice is either are cockroaches exactly cockroach will land on you about it so I'm like have you
seen V little F it's a gem documentary about a like Santa Monica couple who decide to just like have their own Farm that's like um self- sustaining andb no no no made like by Farmland that's been like monocultured in California the soil is completely not they're from Santa Monica they go and byy this monoculture like completely the soil is completely tox because it's just been all of this forcades and they b a self sustaining like also just like every
species like defending like it role and right to be there and like how the Cy aren't pass that they're actually like keeping the groundhogs under like all sorts of like it's wonderful especially for anything my step's really there was a negative sign to the do you that question like ever um no it's really unusual um it's a question I love yeah yeah I think especially cuz like if you think about why would the DC or the regulat feel that way about us putting to well just like breaking systems makes no sense so you guys f b
very little logical s sometimes I mean I think the more work we do the easier it gets um just cuz they see results and once you get to 500 million oysters it's be exactly that's what I'm saying a trillion after you guys like inar Lal area so like it's mostly state right um yeah we work in I think we're working technically in two regions um because up the to is a separate region I believe than like the New York City Long Island area um and of course regions there are different regulations like shell fishing and that I think ties directly into like the amount the water there's a whole sorts of things yeah it's a regulatory battle
that I don't have to fight that works really well yeah no it's um so you full time with may I say yeah I am full yeah no definitely I think just Emil just mention genomics genetics and I'm bed last time Bas we just I just bought like an enemies from like Carolina scientific like but if we get something local and give you guys a little bit of data and even like a pilot
I mean if you want us to yeah i' be happy to see we could probably get you some fresher offers verus some recruits to see what that looks like but [Music] yeah um yeah I hav allow our for up to 500 a year learn how to sequence some things so you are
yeah so nice meeting you nice you to meet you thank you all for coming great
[Music] this one's easy to put [Music]
away I think or
[Music]
I said when I
[Music] come landscape look like more money